John Wolfe, New York (1873–82; bought from the artist during the Salon of 1873; Wolfe sale, Chickering Hall, New York, April 5–6, 1882, no. 50, for $9,700, to Lyall); David C. Lyall, Brooklyn (1882–died 1903; estate sale, American Art Association, New York, February 19, 1903, no. 105, to F. J. Goodwin as agent for Goodnow and Bigelow); Mrs. E. L. Goodnow and Mrs. I. L. Bigelow, Brooklyn, N.Y. (from 1903; on loan to the Brooklyn Museum, 1903–39, when returned to Goodnow family); Goodnow (by 1939); unidentified hotel, Wilkes-Barre, Pa. (until 1980; sold to Michelman); [Joan Michelman, New York, 1980; sold to Ross]; Mr. and Mrs. Frederick C. Ross, New Jersey (1980–99; on loan to MMA, 1996–99; sale, Sotheby's, New York, May 5, 1999, no. 99, bought in); Steven and Alexandra Cohen, Greenwich, Ct. (until 2012; on loan to MMA, 2006–12)
