Jean Antoine Houdon (1788–d. 1828) ; his daughter Sabine Houdon , Paris (1828–d. 1836) ; her grandson Henri Perron , Paris (by descent, 1836–after ca. 1905) ; descended in the family of Henri Perron (until after ca. 1905) ; Jacques-Antoine Doucet (by 1906–12; Doucet sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, January 5–8, 1912, no. 113); [ Duveen Brothers (in 1912; sold to Judge Elbert H. Gary, New York) ] ; Judge Elbert H. Gary , New York (by 1914–28)
; [ Gary sale, American Art Association , New York, April 19–21, 1928, no. 251, unsold ] ; [ sold by private agreement through Knoedler and Co., New York , April 22, 1928; sold to Mrs. E. S. Harkness ] ; Mrs. Edward S. Harkness , New York (1928–d. 1950; bequeathed to MMA)