Dr. Adolf Hommel , Zurich (until 1909; his sale, Kunsthaus Lempertz, Cologne, August 10–18, 1909, no. 425); [ Heilbronner Gallery , Lucerne, in 1957 ] ; Donati Collection ; Ernest Brummer , New York (until 1979; his sale, Galerie Koller AG, Zurich, October 16–19,1979, vol. 1, no. 117); [ Christie's, London (sale, July 3, 1985, no. 118) ] ; [ Black-Nadeau Gallery , London–Monte Carlo ] ; [ Sotheby's, New York (sale, January 29, 1998, no. 138) ] ; [ Christie's, London (sale, July 4, 2000, no. 73) ] ; [ Christie's, London (sale, July 9, 2009, no. 136) ] ; [ Trinity Fine Art Ltd., London (until 2010; sold to MMA) ]