The artist, 1859–84; sale, Ortgies and Company, New York, April 17, 1884, no. 32; Albert Stickney, New York, 1884–died 1908; his wife, New York, 1908–11; sale, Anderson Art Galleries, New York, January 18, 1911, no. 76; Henry Lee Higginson, Boston, 1911–died 1919; his niece, Helene (Mrs. Johan) Durup, Hingham Center, Massachusetts, 1919–34
