Anna Matteoli. Lodovico Cardi-Cigoli pittore e architetto. Pisa, 1980, p. 128, knows this painting only from photographs; relates it to a painting of the same subject, dated 1604, in the church of St. Francis of Assisi, Pisa.
Miles L. Chappell in "Disegno/Incisione/Scultura/Arti minori." Il Seicento Fiorentino: Arte a Firenze da Ferdinando I a Cosimo III. Exh. cat., Palazzo Strozzi. 2, Florence, 1986, p. 122, under no. 2.69, as one of six known painted treatments of this subject.
Franco Faranda. Ludovico Cardi, detto il Cigoli. Rome, 1986, pp. 145, 174, no. 45, ill., knows this painting only from photographs; compares the face of the Madonna to another female figure in a painting in Pistoia of the "Birth of the Madonna"; notes that there is a copy by Cristoforo Allori in the Monti collection, Rome.
Frank Dabell. Important Old Master Paintings: Within the Image. Exh. cat., Piero Corsini, Inc. New York, 1990, pp. 58–61, colorpl. 11, notes that until now the painting was known only from photographs; calls it an example of Cigoli's mature style; notes the presence of a hedgehog on a shield in the lower left corner of the painting, which may be a reference to the Ricciardi family of Arezzo or the Ricci family of Pistoia; says that a drawing in the Louvre (inv. 916r) is preparatory to this painting.
Roberto Contini. Il Cigoli. Soncino, 1991, p. 74, under no. 18.
Andrea Giussani in Pittura italiana dal '300 al '500. Milan, 1991, p. 98, ill. (color).
Miles L. Chappell. Disegni di Lodovico Cigoli (1559–1613). Exh. cat., Galleria degli Uffizi. Florence, 1992, p. 96, under no. 57, associates this painting with a drawing of the same subject in the Uffizi.
Keith Christiansen in "Recent Acquisitions, A Selection: 1991–1992." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 50 (Fall 1992), p. 28, ill. (color).
Miles L. Chappell. "Proposals for Cigoli." Paragone 46 (September 1995), pp. 41, 50 n. 16, lists our painting as one of the versions of this subject that Cigoli painted at the end of the sixteenth century; the other two listed are in the Wadsworth Atheneum in Hartford, Conn., and in the church of San Francesco in Pisa.
Eileen Reeves. Painting the Heavens: Art and Science in the Age of Galileo. Princeton, 1997, pp. 15, 24–25, 38–41, 46, 55, 132, 234 n. 40, colorpl. 1, argues that the moon included in the background of the painting is evidence of Cigloi's interest in astronomy and Galileo's findings about heliocentrism.