Le Charivari (May 29, 1835), ill. (lithograph by Célestin Nanteuil) [excerpt reprinted in Ref. Robaut 1905, vol. 4, p. 353], praises this picture, but observes that it only attracted a small group of connoisseurs at the Salon.
Alexandre-Gabriel Decamps. "Salon de 1835." Revue Républicaine 5 (April 10, 1835), pp. 82, 84 [excerpt reprinted in Ref. Robaut 1905, vol. 4, p. 353], writes with admiration of this picture.
"Salon de 1835 (IIIe article). Les peintres et les poètes." L'Artiste, sér. 1, 9 (1835), pp. 90, 150, praises this picture.
Charles Lenormant. "De l'école française en 1835: Salon annuel." Revue des deux mondes, 4th ser., 2 (April 1, 1835), p. 167 [[reprinted in Lenormant, "Beaux-arts et voyages," Paris, 1861, p. 114], praises the expressive quality of the setting, in which Corot has used details of the Italian landscape.
V[ictor]. Schoelcher. "Salon de 1835. Dernier article." Revue de Paris 17 (May 1835), pp. 165–66, considers it the most beautiful landscape in the exhibition.
A.-D. Vergnaud. Petit pamphlet sur quelques tableaux du Salon de 1835 et sur beaucoup de journalistes qui en ont rendu compte. Paris, 1835 [see Ref. Robaut 1905], expresses dislike for this painting.
L[ouis]. V[iardot]. "Salon de 1835." Le National de 1834 (April 5, 1835), unpaginated, criticizes the execution of this picture, noting, for example, that the rocks should be better grouped and that the angel is too far away.
Théophile Gautier. L'Ariel (March 19, 1836) [excerpt reprinted in Gautier, "Critique d'Art: Extraits des Salons (1833–1872)," Paris, 1994, p. 123], praises this picture.
[Louis Batissier?]. "Salon de 1837." L'Artiste, sér. 1, 13 (1837), pp. 146–47, calls it an estimable but incomplete work.
Théophile Gautier. "Variétés. Beaux-arts. Topographie du Salon." La Presse (March 8, 1837), p. 4, mentions this picture in relation to Corot's "Saint Jerome" (1837; R366; Church of Saint-Nicolas-Saint-Marc, Ville-d'Avray).
Louis Viardot. "Beaux-Arts. Salon de 1837. -Septième article." Le Siècle (April 17, 1837), p. 1.
Jules Janin. "Salon de 1839 (cinquième article)." L'Artiste, sér. 2, 2 (1839), p. 271.
Ad[olphe]. Desbarrolles. "Notes sur la vie d'artiste (5e article)." Bulletin de l'ami des arts 2 (1844), p. 17, states that this picture was poorly hung at the Salon in the dark galleries known as the Catacombes.
Théophile Silvestre. Histoire des artistes vivants: Français et étrangers. Paris, 1856, pp. 94, 102, 104, quotes Corot's criticism of the model for Hagar; compares this picture to a landscape by Aligny.
Paul Mantz. "Artistes contemporains: Corot." Gazette des beaux-arts 11 (November 1, 1861), p. 422, states that this picture was recently exhibited at the boulevard des Italiens [see Exh. Paris 1861].
"Société nationale des beaux-arts." Le Courrier artistique 2 (June 15, 1862), p. 2, lists it among the pictures marked for sale in an exhibition at the Société Nationale des Beaux-Arts [Exh. Paris 1862].
Camille Corot. Letter to Auguin. January 15,  [excerpt published in Ref. Robaut 1905, vol. 4, p. 345], mentions that this picture is not in current fashion.
Édouard Daliphard. "Exposition des œuvres de Corot." L'Art 2 (May 30, 1875), p. 159, notes that it was purchased a few days ago by prince Soutzo.
Jean Rousseau. "Corot." L'Art 1 (March 14, 1875), p. 246.
Charles Bigot. Peintres français contemporains. Paris, 1888, p. 51.
L[éon]. Roger-Milès. "Corot." Les artistes célèbres. 32, Paris, , pp. 26–28, 32, 82, suggests that the landscape in this picture is based on studies of the Italian Tyrol.
A. Larthe-Ménager. "Corot (1796–1875)." Les Contemporains 3 (October 7, 1894), p. 14, states erroneously that Corot left this picture to the Louvre in his will.
John W. Mollett. The Painters of Barbizon: Millet, Rousseau, Diaz, Corot, Daubigny, Dupré. London, 1895, pp. 14, 31.
L[éon]. Roger-Milès. Album classique des chefs-d'œuvre de Corot. Paris, 1895, pp. 35–36, 56, ill., locates it in the collection of Doria.
André Michel. Notes sur l'art moderne (peinture). Paris, 1896, pp. 18–19, 24, states that Corot used a study of trees in Fontainebleau (MMA 1979.404) for the group of trees to the left of the angel; asserts that he worked from a live model for this picture
Gustave Geffroy in "Jean-Baptiste Camille Corot." Corot and Millet. New York, 1903, pp. cxi, cxiii, states that Corot made studies for this picture in the town of Volterra in Tuscany.
Ethel Birnstingl and Alice Pollard. Corot. London, 1904, pp. 25–26, 62, 166, 177, call it "Hagar in the Wilderness" in the text and "Hagar in the Desert" in the list of works; note the classical influence in this picture.
Maurice Hamel. Corot et son œuvre. Paris, 1905, vol. 1, pp. 15, 18, pl. 7.
Julius Meier-Graefe. Corot und Courbet: Ein Beitrag zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Modernen Malerei. Leipzig, 1905, pp. 21–22, 29–31, 50 [English translation published in Ref. Meier-Graefe 1908; reprinted in Ref. Meier-Graefe 1913].
Émile Michel. "Corot." Les artistes célèbres. 57, Paris, , p. 24, tentatively dates it before Corot's second trip to Italy; recognizes the Roman countryside, possibly at Castel Sant' Elia, in the background and the rocks at Fontainebleau in the foreground.
[Adolphe-]Étienne Moreau-Nélaton in Alfred Robaut. L'Œuvre de Corot: Catalogue raisonné et illustré. [reprint 1965]. Paris, 1905, vol. 1, pp. 62, 73, 79, 82 [reprinted in Ref. Moreau-Nélaton 1924], comments that Corot began this picture in 1833, but abandoned it until his return from his second trip to Italy; states that it was intended as a pendant to Corot's "Saint-Jerome" (R366; Ville-d'Avray).
Alfred Robaut. L'Œuvre de Corot: Catalogue raisonné et illustré. [reprint 1965]. Paris, 1905, vol. 2, pp. 98, 126–27, no. 362, ill.; vol. 4, pp. 96, 167, 171, 202, 277, 295, 345, 353, calls it "Agar dans le désert" and dates it 1834–35; identifies the first study for this painting in a notebook dated about 1833 (R3097).
Julius Meier-Graefe. Modern Art, Being a Contribution to a New System of Aesthetics. London, 1908, vol. 1. pp. 164–65, 167–68, 173, 182, remarks that this picture's "superficial conventionality tempts us to overlook all there is of Corot in the picture"; locates it in the Gallimard collection.
Raymond Bouyer. "Corot, peintre de figures." Revue de l'art ancien et moderne 26 (October 1909), p. 300.
Julius Meier-Graefe. Camille Corot. 3rd ed. Munich, 1913, pp. 28, 31, 34, ill. p. 23.
Léon Rosenthal. Du Romantisme au réalisme: essai sur l'évolution de la peinture en France de 1830 à 1848. Paris, 1914, p. 285.
Karl Madsen. Corot og Hans Billeder, I Nordisk Eie. Copenhagen, 1920, pp. 18–20, ill.
Étienne Moreau-Nélaton. Corot raconté par lui-même. 2nd rev. ed. (1st ed., 1905). Paris, 1924, vol. 1, pp. 32, 39–40, 43–44, fig. 58; vol. 2, p. 158, notes that the young women who worked for Corot's mother posed for his figures of Hagar and Rebecca (R382; Norton Simon Foundation, Pasadena, Calif.).
Marc Lafargue. Corot. London, 1926, pp. 39–41, places it in Corot's classical period, between his Italian paintings and those of the Mortefontaine period.
"Jean-Baptiste Corot (1796–1875): Compositions Classiques." Documents 1 (April–December 1929), ill. p. 89, as "Agar," in the collection of Mlle Dieterle.
C. Bernheim de Villers. Corot: Peintre de figures. Paris, 1930, p. 31, observes that this was the first picture exhibited by Corot in which the figure plays an important role.
Julius Meier-Graefe. Corot. Berlin, 1930, p. 48, comments on the influence of Bertin in this picture; questions whether the drawing (Musée du Louvre, Paris) of one of his mother's dressmakers, later identified by Corot as "my Hagar," is actually related to this painting [see Ref. Moreau-Nélaton 1905, pp. 54–55].
"From Corot's Youth." Art Digest 13 (December 1, 1938), p. 9, ill.
"An Early Corot Masterpiece for the Metropolitan: 'Hagar in the Wilderness'." Art News 37 (November 19, 1938), p. 8, ill.
"Activity." Magazine of Art 31 (December 1938), pp. 716–17, ill.
Harry B. Wehle. "Hagar in the Wilderness by Corot." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 33 (November 1938), pp. 246–49, ill., remarks that although this picture was painted in Paris, the head of Hagar resembles sketches from Corot's first trip to Italy in 1825–28 and the landscape is based on studies made in the Sabine mountains near Narni and Terni.
James W. Lane. "Notes from New York." Apollo 29 (January 1939), pp. 35–37, ill., compares the execution of the trees and the "tawniness of the colours" with Derain.
Art News Annual (1945–46), p. 90, ill., calls it a landscape in the tradition of Poussin.
Henri Marceau. Corot 1796–1875. Exh. cat., Philadelphia Museum of Art. Philadelphia, 1946, pp. 17, 30, no. 18, ill. [includes reprint of Ref. Venturi 1947], calls it "Hagar in the Desert"; states that the landscape was created from sketches or recollections of the Tuscan countryside; comments that this picture was the first to bring Corot success.
Lionello Venturi. Modern Painters. 1, New York, 1947, p. 148.
Joseph C. Sloane. French Painting Between the Past and the Present: Artists, Critics, and Traditions, from 1848 to 1870. [reprint 1973]. Princeton, 1951, pp. xi, 125, fig. 3.
Daniel Baud-Bovy. Corot. Geneva, 1957, pp. 45, 85, 121–22, 187, 202–4, identifies the sitter in the Louvre drawing of a young woman (R2652) as Alexina Legoux, Corot's favorite of his mother's employees, calling her the inspiration for our painting; criticizes the lack of unity in the composition of the painting and the theatricality of the studio model who actually posed for the figure of Hagar.
François Fosca. Corot, sa vie et son oeuvre. Brussels, 1958, pp. 23, 145, 190, relates it to the historic landscape tradition of Poussin and Claude, and compares its austerity and simplicity to Puvis de Chavannes.
André Coquis. Corot et la critique contemporaine. Paris, 1959, pp. 18–20, 22–23, 25, 46, 71.
Denys Sutton. Corot. Exh. cat., Marlborough Fine Art Ltd. London, 1963, p. 8, discusses it in the context of historical landscapes.
Cecil Gould. Corot. Exh. cat., Edinburgh International Festival. London, 1965, unpaginated, no. 33, pl. 24.
Charles Sterling and Margaretta M. Salinger. "XIX Century." French Paintings: A Catalogue of the Collection of The Metropolitan Museum of Art. 2, New York, 1966, pp. 48–50, ill., remark that although this composition was based on sketches made in Cività Castellana during Corot's first Italian trip as well as studies of the Fontainebleau forest, "the general character of the whole landscape... was surely inspired by memories of his more recent trip to central Italy"; mention the first notebook sketch (R3097), several studies (R135–40, 246A, 278), the drawing of a young woman (Louvre), a painted sketch [see Ref. Bazin 1973], and an engraving on glass (R3207).
Anne Reverdy. L'École de Barbizon: Évolution du prix des tableaux de 1850 à 1960. Mouton, , p. 56.
Madeleine Hours. Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot. New York, , pp. 90–91, ill. (color).
Germain Bazin. Corot. 3rd rev. ed. (1st ed., 1942; 2nd ed., 1951). Paris, 1973, pp. 10, 40–41, 264, 281, reproduces a smaller version of this composition, which does not include the angel, calling it a study for our painting (formerly collection Georges Renand, Paris) [see Ref. Pantazzi 1996].
Pierre Miquel. "1824–1874." Le Paysage français au XIXe siècle. 2, Maurs-la-jolie, 1975, pp. 18–19.
Hélène Toussaint in Hommage à Corot: Peintures et dessins des collections françaises. Exh. cat., Orangerie des Tuileries. Paris, 1975, pp. 69, 75, 181, calls it Corot's most dramatic work.
Anthony F. Janson. "Corot: Tradition and the Muse." Art Quarterly, n.s., 1, no. 4 (1978), p. 298, notes this picture's combination of stylistic and topographical features from both Italy and the North.
Charles S. Moffett and Anne Wagner in The Metropolitan Museum of Art: Notable Acquisitions, 1979–1980. New York, 1980, p. 43.
Carla Maria Puppin. "The Critical Response to Landscape Painting in France, 1830–1851." PhD diss., Bryn Mawr College, 1986, p. 20.
Collection Georges Renand. Drouot-Montaigne. November 20, 1987, unpaginated, under no. 12.
Jean Selz. La Vie et l'œuvre de Camille Corot. Paris, 1988, pp. 102, 104, 107, 134, ill. (color), comments that the publication of Nanteuil's lithograph [see Ref. Charivari 1835] was a sign of the contemporary success of this picture; based on notes made by Robaut, suggests that the inspiration for Hagar was another employee of Corot's mother named Zoe, and that it was probably she who posed for the Louvre drawing known as "mon Agar," although she did not pose for our painting [see Ref. Silvestre 1856].
Fronia E. Wissman. "Corot's Salon Paintings: Sources from French Classicism to Contemporary Theater Design." PhD diss., Yale University, 1989, vol. 1, pp. 94, 96–98, 106, 160, 191, 198, no. 11, fig. 45, discusses it among other Corot pictures of solitary figures with historical and biblical themes, such as "Saint Jerome" (R366, Ville-d'Avray), "A Monk" (R375, Musée du Louvre, Paris), "Christ in the Garden of Gethsemane" (R610, Musée de Langres), and "Saint Sebastian"(R1063B, Walters Art Museum, Baltimore); remarks that this picture "conveys the plight of the outcasts through the landscape itself"; compares it to Millet's painting of the same subject (1848–49, The Hague).
Peter Galassi in Claude to Corot: The Development of Landscape Painting in France. Exh. cat., Colnaghi. New York, 1990, p. 246, fig. 16.
Michael Clarke. Corot and the Art of Landscape. London, 1991, pp. 56–58, 60, colorpl. 63, erroneously dates it 1815 in the caption; suggests that Corot referred to the Louvre drawing of a young woman as "mon Agar" because his family disapproved of their romantic involvement.
Peter Galassi. Corot in Italy: Open-Air Painting and the Classical-Landscape Tradition. New Haven, 1991, pp. 80–81, pl. 94.
Jean Leymarie. Corot. 3rd ed. (1st ed., 1966). [Geneva], 1992, p. 75, ill. (color) [English ed., 1979].
Michael Clarke. "Corot: Between the Classical and the Modern." Cezanne & Poussin: A Symposium. Sheffield, 1993, pp. 80–81, pl. 22.
Iain Gale. Corot. London, 1994, pp. 22, 70–71, 114, ill. (color), notes that the overall tonal treatment recalls Aligny; calls this painting a historical landscape focusing on the action of the protagonists, as in the work of Poussin, rather than a landscape history painting, as advocated by Corot's mentor Michallon.
François Fossier et al. "Corot." Connaissance des arts [special exhibition issue for "Corot, 1796–1875"] (1996), pp. 28, 32, fig. 30 (color).
Manuel Jover and Vincent Pomarède. "Camille Corot." Beaux Arts [special exhibition issue for "Corot 1796–1875"] (1996), pp. 14, 43, fig. 39 (color).
Michael Pantazzi in Corot. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1996, pp. xiv, 141, 153–57, 159, 175, 183, 186, 400, 402, 411, no. 61, ill. pp. 154–55 and fig. 62 (color, overall and detail) [Fr. ed., "Corot 1796–1875," Paris, 1996, pp. 21, 195, 206, 208–10, 226, 236, 240, 466–67, ill. (color)], suggests that the oil sketch (formerly collection Renand) was not a study for this painting, but rather a derivation from it; notes that the rocks, trees, and background were based on studies made at Fontainebleau and Civita Castellana; remarks that Corot's inscription, "Agar, vers 1830," on the Louvre drawing of a young woman seems to confirm its connection to the painting, but doubts the identification of the sitter as Alexina Legoux; suggests the influence of Pier Francesca Mola's "The Angel Appearing to Hagar in the Desert" (1612–66; Musée du Louvre, Paris); mentions a possible connection between the theme of motherhood and despair in this painting with the death of the only child of one of Corot's friends, Mme André Osmond
Vincent Pomarède in Corot. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1996, pp. 27, 74, 84, 135 [Fr. ed., "Corot 1796–1875," Paris, 1996, pp. 64, 120, 129, 188].
Gary Tinterow in Corot. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1996, p. 271 [French ed., "Corot 1796–1875," Paris, 1996, p. 334].
Colin B. Bailey in Colin B. Bailey. Renoir's Portraits: Impressions of an Age. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa. New Haven, 1997, p. 217.
Patricia Mainardi. "Corot entre deux chaises." Corot, un artiste et son temps. Paris, 1998, p. 169.
Vincent Pomarède. "Le Souvenir recomposé. Réflexions autour du thème du "souvenir" dans l'œuvre de Corot." Corot, un artiste et son temps. Paris, 1998, pp. 433, 581.
Anne Roquebert. "Quelques observations sur la technique de Corot." Corot, un artiste et son temps. Paris, 1998, pp. 99, 112.
Cesare de Seta. "Prima di Corot. Pittori e scrittori tra Roma e Napoli." Corot, un artiste et son temps. Paris, 1998, p. 394.
Fronia E. Wissman. "Arbres torturés, ailes de fées: les sources des peintures de Salon de Corot." Corot, un artiste et son temps. Paris, 1998, p. 254.
Jed Perl. Eyewitness: Reports from an Art World in Crisis. New York, 2000, p. 219, remarks that it has "a clean-lined, off-balance beauty that is far from Neoclassical conventions".
Vincent Pomarède in Maestà di Roma, da Napoleone all'unita d'Italia: D'Ingres à Degas, les artistes français à Rome. Exh. cat., Villa Medici, Rome. [Milan], 2003, p. 380 under no. 183, states that the landscape around Cervara, south of Rome, served numerous works by Corot and other artists that were exhibited at the Salon.
Susan Greenberg. "Reforming 'Paysage Historique': Corot and the Generation of 1830." Art History 27 (June 2004), pp. 413–14, 418–22, 426–27 n. 6, p. 429 n. 25, p. 430 n. 41, pl. 3.6, discusses it as a historical landscape which "spoke to Salon viewers in ways that descriptive naturalism could not"; relates Corot's resurrection of the dying genre of historical landscape to the story of Hagar and Ishmael's near death and notes that the construction of the figures' meandering route "emphasizes the experience of dislocation and displacement that characterizes both the picture's theme and the spectator's experience of the landscape"; perceives an element of fear in this picture's "choleric" greenish-yellow tones.
Michael Clarke in Corot: Naturaleza, Emoción, Recuerdo. Exh. cat., Museo Thyssen-Bornemisza. Madrid, 2005, pp. 24, 331, fig. A.6 (color).
Vincent Pomarède in Corot: Naturaleza, Emoción, Recuerdo. Exh. cat., Museo Thyssen-Bornemisza. Madrid, 2005, pp. 43, 45–46, 274, 306, 338–39, 342, 390, 398, fig. B.5 (color detail).
Petra ten-Doesschate Chu. Nineteenth-Century European Art. 2nd ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J., 2006, pp. 237–38, fig. 10-15 (color).
Katherine Rothkopf. Pissarro: Creating the Impressionist Landscape. Exh. cat., Baltimore Museum of Art. London, 2006, p. 45.
Simon Kelly in The Repeating Image: Multiples in French Painting from David to Matisse. Exh. cat., Walters Art Museum. Baltimore, 2007, p. 76 n. 50, calls it "Hagar and the Angel".
Arlette Sérullaz. Corot. Milan, 2007, p. 71, under no. 12, doubts the authenticity of the inscription "mon Agar" on the Louvre drawing.
Gary Tinterow in The Masterpieces of French Painting from The Metropolitan Museum of Art: 1800–1920. Exh. cat., Museum of Fine Arts, Houston. New York, 2007, p. 26.
Simon Kelly in Kimberly Jones. In the Forest of Fontainebleau: Painters and Photographers from Corot to Monet. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Art. Washington, 2008, p. 144, as "Hagar and the Angel".
Michael Pantazzi in Jane Kinsman. Degas: The Uncontested Master. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Australia. Canberra, 2008, p. 260 n. 6.
Vincent Pomarède in Corot: Souvenirs et variations. Exh. cat., National Museum of Western Art. Tokyo, 2008, pp. 22–23, 252, fig. 15.
Nathalie Michel-Szelechowska in Corot e l'arte moderna. Souvenirs et Impressions. Exh. cat., Palazzo della Gran Guardia, Verona. Venice, 2009, p. 74.
Vincent Pomarède in Corot e l'arte moderna. Souvenirs et Impressions. Exh. cat., Palazzo della Gran Guardia, Verona. Venice, 2009, pp. 13, 53, fig. 14 (color).
Vincent Pomarède. Jean-Baptiste Camille Corot: Souvenir de Mortefontaine. Paris, 2010, p. 10, fig. 15 (color).
Vincent Pomarède in Corot. L'Armoire secrète: Eine Lesende im Kontext. Exh. cat., Sammlung Oskar Reinhart Am Römerholz, Winterthur. Munich, 2011, p. 26, fig. 9 (color).