The quilt is composed of pieced blocks with patches of solid brown, pumpkin gold, red, and pine-green cotton. Each piece is quilted individually around the edge. The medium brown border is quilted with feather vines and diagonal lines. All the quilting is hand stitched with brown thread. The quilt is backed with a small-scale brown floral-printed cotton.
The Pineapple variation of the Log Cabin quilt is thought to be related to eighteenth-century symbolism, in which pineapples represented hospitality. This Pennsylvania quilt, pieced of gold, red, green, and earth-brown cotton, is one of the more literal representations of the pineapple theme. In the Pineapple variation of a Log Cabin quilt, the central squares or "hearths" of each block are not a primary element in the design. The central squares of each block in this quilt are cut from the same brown fabric as the border and also as some of the pineapple leaves. In the Pineapple pattern, the central square is not surrounded by four "logs" of fabric, but rather by eight overlapping logs, both parallel with and at forty-five-degree angles to the central square's sides. This pattern, also known as Windmill Blades, can be quite dizzying when pieced with printed fabrics, but when superbly planned, as in this example, it is a pattern of great strength and energy.
Although Mennonites and Amish quiltmakers share some distinctive traditions, including a preference for solid-color fabrics and detailed, graceful quilting in the borders, there are practices that distinguish the two communities. Several features of this quilt, for example, suggest that it was likely created by a Mennonite, rather than an Amish, maker. First, Log Cabin quilts, which were accepted and admired in the Mennonite community, were rarely made by the Amish. Second, it is made completely of cotton and uses a bright color palette, including a golden yellow, which is more typical of Mennonite quilts. The Pennsylvania Amish usually made quilts that were predominantly wool and favored more subtle shades of blue and purple. Mennonites continue to share many beliefs with the Amish but are not as intent upon keeping their communities firmly separated from the outside world, and they do not believe in shunning those who may have strayed from the faith. Mennonite quilt makers from Pennsylvania have kept closer ties with the general Pennsylvania German community; this explains why they use a wider array of patterns and fabrics.
[Peck 2015; adapted from Amelia Peck, "American Quilts & Coverlets in the Metropolitan Museum of Art," 2007]