Purchase, European Paintings Funds, Lila Acheson Wallace Gift, Catharine Lorillard Wolfe Collection, Wolfe Fund, Charles and Jessie Price Gift, funds from various donors, and Bequests of Collis P. Huntington and Isaac D. Fletcher, by exchange, 2013
This powerful and haunting picture is among the ambitious Symbolist compositions that established Hodler’s fame in Europe around 1900, on a par with Edvard Munch and Gustav Klimt. When the painting was first shown during the Swiss national exhibition in Geneva in 1896, critics detected an ironic edge, perhaps because of its venue: a theater associated with the satirical journal Le Sapajou. Hodler’s suggestive vision of naked women may have been a rejoinder to officials who objected to the display of his painting The Night (1889–90; Kunstmuseum Bern), finding its seminude, male and female figures excessively erotic.
Born in 1853 to a carpenter in Bern, Hodler apprenticed in Thun under his stepfather, the decorative painter Gottlieb Schüpbach (1814–1873), and then with Ferdinand Sommer (1822–1901), a specialist in picturesque Alpine views, before departing in 1871 for Geneva, the artistic center of Switzerland. Between 1872 and 1877 he trained with the landscapist Barthélemy Menn (1815–1893) and studied the work of Dürer and Courbet. By the early 1880s Hodler had developed a robust Realist style, but around this time he began to frequent Symbolist circles, which brought him into closer contact with the Paris art world, most notably the paintings of Puvis de Chavannes. While retaining aspects of his earlier naturalism, Hodler was increasingly fascinated by allegory and abstract ideals. The Dream of the Shepherd belongs to the ambitious Symbolist compositions that established his reputation in Europe at the turn of the twentieth century, on a par with Edvard Munch and Gustav Klimt. In these works, Hodler explored such universal and psychologically fraught themes as sleep, dreams, death, and love, often with erotic overtones. Sources from the first half of the twentieth century tend to date The Dream of the Shepherd to 1893 (see, e.g., Loosli 1922). More recently, the painting has been dated to 1896, the year it was first shown at the Swiss national exhibition in Geneva (Fischer 2009). Hodler was a considerable presence at the exhibition: he worked on the painted decoration for the Palais des Beaux-Arts; showed five pictures in the main venue; and contributed The Dream of the Shepherd and another oil, Towards the Ideal (unlocated) to the "Exposition Fantaisiste," held in the Théâtre du Sapajou, a theater on the grounds of the national exhibition used for light entertainment. The two "decorative panels," as they were described in the catalogue, flanked the entrance to the theater (photo SIK-ISEA, Schweizersches Kunstarchiv, permanent loan, Musée d’art et d’histoire, Neuchâtel; see Additional Images, fig. 1). In Towards the Ideal, Hodler reprised the seminude, sleeping couple in the lower right corner of his controversial painting The Night (1889–90, now Kunstmuseum Bern), switching the figures to a vertical orientation so that they appear to float in space. The Dream of the Shepherd similarly conjures an otherworldly realm, suffused with strains of erotic desire. The canvas is divided into two zones: in the lower, terrestrial zone, a young shepherd—a popular character in Swiss folklore—kneels amid a rocky landscape dotted with small red flowers (Paul Müller in Christie's, Zürich, sale cat., December 11, 2013, p. 39, under no. 40). He buries his head in his left hand, which covers his entire face, while with his right arm he holds a long shepherd’s staff. His flock is nowhere in sight. The life-size figure, painted from a local model, relates to Hodler’s earlier, realistic depictions of peasants, warriors, and beggars, but displays a new psychological intensity; the deeply expressive and powerful pose is highly reminiscent of the damned souls in Michelangelo’s fresco of the Last Judgment in the Sistine Chapel in Rome. In the upper zone of the canvas, above the horizon of the distant hill, appear what Hodler described in a sketchbook as "white women on a white sky, which is crossed horizontally by blue clouds" (ca. 1895, Cabinet d’arts graphiques du Musée d’art et d’histoire, Geneva, carnet inv. 1958-176/32.06; see Additional Images, fig. 2). The stylized gestures of the eight naked women evoke the nascent modern dance movement, while the decorative, frieze-like arrangement of the figures recalls the work of Puvis de Chavannes, which was much admired by Hodler. The women’s pale, ethereal forms mark them as apparitions, in stark contrast to the shepherd’s muscular body, rendered with naturalistic detail. There are several studies for the composition. One sketch appears to show the shepherd accompanied by additional figures, with the frieze of women overhead (ca. 1895, Cabinet d’arts graphiques du Musée d’art et d’histoire, Geneva; carnet inv. 1958-176/116.11; see also 1958-176/116.17; see Additional Images, figs. 3–4). Two others depict the shepherd beneath a sun, which takes the form of a female head surrounded by a halo of rays (ca. 1895, Cabinet d’arts graphiques du Musée d’art et d’histoire, Geneva; carnet inv.1958-176/10.12; 1958-176/116.08; see also 1958-176/116.07; see Additional Images, figs. 5–7). These last drawings link The Dream of the Shepherd with Hodler’s attempts to express mankind’s striving toward light and enlightenment, as in works such as The Day (1899, Kunstmuseum Bern), which presents hieratically posed female nudes as symbols of radiance and harmony with nature. The women in The Dream of the Shepherd have been similarly interpreted as embodiments of light and as conduits for divine illumination (Müller in Christie's, Zürich, sale cat., December 11, 2013, p. 39, under no. 40). Critics at the Sapajou exhibition of 1896 suspected that Hodler’s painting was not entirely in earnest. One writer wondered whether the artist was engaged in "mysticism or mystification," adding, "You have the right to be uncertain, you’re at the Sapajou" (Serment 1896; see also Vallette 1896). As this remark indicates, the doubt about Hodler’s intentions stemmed partly from his choice of venue. The Théâtre du Sapajou derived its name from a satirical journal, and the catalogue for the "Exposition Fantaisiste," decorated with sketches of monkeys and a dog in fancy dress, conveys a lightly mocking tone. It has been argued that The Dream of the Shepherd and Towards the Ideal were meant as a rejoinder to the conservative attitudes that had blocked the display of The Night at the Musée Rath in Geneva in 1891 and again at the national exhibition in 1896 (Fischer 2009). The painting, with its realistically depicted, undressed men and women in suggestive postures, was deemed provocative and immoral, earning Hodler considerable notoriety. [Alison Hokanson 2014]
Inscription: Signed (lower left): F. Hodler
Hans Beat Wieland, Munich, later Schwyz (bought from the artist; 1896–1920, sold to Kunsthandlung Rath); [Kunsthandlung Rath, Basel, 1920–21; sold for CHF 40,000 to private collection, Basel]; private collection, Basel (by family descent, 1921–2013; sale, Christie's, Zürich, December 11, 2013, no. 34, to MMA)
Geneva. Théâtre du Sapajou. "Exposition Fantaisiste," May 3–October 18, 1896, no. 12 (as "Rêve de pâtre").
Kunsthaus Zürich. May 8–June 1, 1919, no. 120 [see Christie's sale cat. 2013].
Kunstmuseum Solothurn. "Leihgabe aus Basler Privatbesitz," 192[?] [see Christie's sale cat. 2013].
Kunstmuseum Bern. "Hodler Gedächtnis-Ausstellung," August 20–October 23, 1891, no. 245 (as "Traum des Hirten," 1893, lent by Kunsthandlung Rath, Basel).
Kunsthalle Basel. "Kunstwerke des 19. Jahrhunderts aus Basler Privatbesitz," May 1–July 4, 1943, no. 328 (as 1893).
W[illiam]. S[erment]. "Exposition Nationale: Au Sapajou." Journal de Genève (May 6, 1896), p. 3, mentions "two large canvases by Hodler" that hang "to the right and the left of the entrance".
Paul Seippel. "Le Sapajou." Journal de Genève (May 11, 1896), p. 1.
[Gaspard] V[allette]. "A l'Exposition nationale suisse: La Peinture Fantaisiste au Sapajou." Gazette de Lausanne (June 23, 1896), p. 2.
G. "Exposition nationale suisse: Le Sapajou." Courrier de Genève (May 13, 1896), p. 3 [see Fischer 2009, who variously attributes the article to the "Courrier de Genève" and "Le Soir. Second Feuille du Journal de Genève"].
C[arl]. A[lbert]. Loosli. Ferdinand Hodler: Leben, Werk und Nachlass. Vol. 2, Das Werk Ferdinand Hodler's von 1870 bis 1889. Bern, 1922, p. 181, states that the painting was made shortly after Hodler's return from a trip to the Swiss canton of Ticino in 1893; criticizes the composition, handling of the figure, and color.
C[arl]. A[lbert]. Loosli. Ferdinand Hodler: Leben, Werk und Nachlass. Vol. 4, Urkunden. Bern, 1924, p. 139, no. 2111.
Hans von Matt. Hans Beat Wieland: Leben und Werk 1867–1945. Zürich, 1977, p. 61, writes that Wieland "was proud that he possessed a large figure painting by the master, which occupied the first place in his collection" (probably this picture).
Matthias Fischer. Der junge Hodler: Eine Künstlerkarriere, 1872–1897. Wädenswil, Switzerland, 2009, pp. 210–11, 255 n. 691, fig. 262, dates it 1896; suggests that this work represents the fantasies of a shepherd, who symbolizes the healthy body and mind of Swiss peasant youth; argues that the painting and its companion in the 1896 exhibition, "Towards the Ideal," were intended as a rejoinder to the narrow-minded and hypocritical attitudes that had prevented Hodler's painting "The Night" (1889–90) from being shown at official exhibitions in Geneva.