Victor Lasareff. "Two Newly-Discovered Pictures of the Lucca School." Burlington Magazine 51 (August 1927), pp. 56–57, 61–62, pl. I, attributes it to Berlinghiero or one of his immediate followers and dates it to the first quarter of the thirteenth century; observes a strong Byzantine influence and notes that the iconography of the Virgin belongs to the Hodegetria type [see Notes].
Evelyn Sandberg-Vavalà. La croce dipinta italiana. 1985 ed. Rome, 1929, pp. 548, 568 n. 5, accepts the attribution to Berlinghiero.
Lionello Venturi. Pitture italiane in America. Milan, 1931, unpaginated, pl. II, tentatively ascribes it to Jacopo Torriti.
Raimond van Marle. Le scuole della pittura italiana. Vol. 1, Dal VI alla fine del XIII secolo. The Hague, 1932, p. 315 n.1, judging from reproductions only, finds it more Byzantine than the recognized works of Berlinghiero but rejects the attribution to Jacopo Torriti.
Lionello Venturi. Italian Paintings in America. Vol. 1, Romanesque and Gothic. New York, 1933, unpaginated, pl. 2, tentatively ascribes it to Jacopo Torriti.
Evelyn Sandberg Vavalà. L'iconografia della Madonna col Bambino nella pittura italiana del dugento. Siena, 1934, p. 39, no. 90, pl. XIV A, as by Berlinghiero; places it under the Hodegetria type [see Notes].
Paolo d'Ancona. Les primitifs italiens du XIe au XIIIe siècle. Paris, 1935, p. 66, considers it probably a work of Berlinghiero
Giulia Sinibaldi and Giulia Brunetti, ed. Pittura italiana del duecento e trecento: Catalogo della mostra giottesca di Firenze del 1937. Exh. cat., Galleria degli Uffizi. Florence, 1943, p. 11, no. 3, ill. p. 10, state that the attribution to Berlinghiero is uncertain; find some formal elements inconsistent with the artist's other works.
Edward B. Garrison Jr. "A Berlinghieresque Fresco in S. Stefano, Bologna." Art Bulletin 28 (December 1946), pp. 213–14, 216 n. 33, 217–18, fig. 8, discusses it in the text as a work painted by Berlinghiero considerably later than the signed cross in the Museo Nazionale di Villa Guinigi, Lucca [see Notes], but questions this attribution in the caption to the illustration
Edward B. Garrison. "Post-War Discoveries—III: The 'Madonna "di sotto gli organi"'." Burlington Magazine 89 (1947), pp. 278–79, pl. I A, accepts the attribution to Berlinghiero and dates it about 1230; compares it to the "Madonna di sotto gli organi" in the cathedral at Pisa, ascribed to the same artist.
Roberto Longhi. "Giudizio sul Duecento." Proporzioni 2 (1948), p. 30, cites the entry in the Sinibaldi and Brunetti catalogue [see Ref. 1943]; rejects the attribution to Jacopo Torriti and considers it a work of Berlinghiero.
Edward B. Garrison. Italian Romanesque Panel Painting. Florence, 1949, pp. 12, 59, no. 96, ill., reports that it was in the Volpi collection, Florence, by 1925, and with the Florentine dealer Italo before that; attributes it to Berlinghiero and dates it 1230–40.
Edward B. Garrison. "Toward a New History of Early Lucchese Painting." Art Bulletin 33 (March 1951), p. 15, mentions it as a late work of Berlinghiero, placing it towards the end of his life.
Robert Oertel. "Ein toskanisches Madonnenbild um 1260." Mitteilungen des Kunsthistorischen Institutes in Florenz 7 (October 1953), p. 24 n. 43, calls it a work of the school of Berlinghiero.
Dorothy C. Shorr. The Christ Child in Devotional Images in Italy During the XIV Century. New York, 1954, p. 14, ill. p. 18, considers it the first image of its type to appear in Italian panel painting; attributes it to Berlinghiero and dates it about 1240
Edward B. Garrison. "Addenda ad indicem—III." Bollettino d'arte 41 (1956), p. 309, dates it 1230–40.
W. R. Valentiner. "A Madonna by Berlinghiero Berlinghieri." North Carolina Museum of Art Bulletin 1 (Summer 1957), p. 3, compares it with a Madonna and Child attributed to Berlinghiero in the North Carolina Museum of Art, Raleigh; says that it has been assigned to Berlinghiero or to his son Bonaventura but does not give the source of the latter attribution.
Hellmut Hager. Die Anfänge des italienischen Altarbildes: Untersuchungen zur Entstehungsgeschichte des toskanischen Hochaltarretabels. Munich, 1962, p. 81, fig. 102, erroneously as still in the Strauss [sic] collection, New York; attributes it Berlinghiero and repeats Garrison's dating of 1230–40 [see Ref. 1949].
James H. Stubblebine. Guido da Siena. Princeton, 1964, p. 78, fig. 104, erroneously as still in the Straus collection, New York; attributes it to Berlinghiero and compares it with Guido da Siena's Madonna in the Princeton University Art Museum.
Viktor Lazarev. Storia della pittura bizantina. Italian ed. Turin, 1967, pp. 323, 336 n. 60, erroneously as still in the Strauss [sic] collection, New York; calls it a work of Berlinghiero inspired by Byzantine prototypes.
Henry S. Francis. "The Stoclet Tabernacle." Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art 54 (April 1967), p. 95, erroneously as still in the Straus collection, New York.
Bernard Berenson. Italian Pictures of the Renaissance: Central Italian and North Italian Schools. London, 1968, vol. 1, p. 47, lists it as a work by Berlinghiero.
Federico Zeri with the assistance of Elizabeth E. Gardner. Italian Paintings: A Catalogue of the Collection of The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Florentine School. New York, 1971, pp. 1–3, ill., call it one of three works surely painted by Berlinghiero himself [see Notes]; date it to the end of the artist's career, about 1240.
Everett Fahy. "Florentine Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum: An Exhibition and a Catalogue." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 29 (June 1971), pp. 431–32, ill., cites Zeri's opinion that it is one of only three pictures that can be ascribed to Berlinghiero himself [see Ref. Zeri and Gardner 1971].
Everett Fahy. "Letter from New York: Florentine Paintings at the Metropolitan." Apollo 94 (August 1971), pp. 150–51, fig. 1, cites Zeri's opinion that it is one of only three pictures that can be ascribed to Berlinghiero himself [see Ref. Zeri and Gardner 1971].
Edmund P. Pillsbury. Florence and the Arts: Five Centuries of Patronage. Exh. cat., Cleveland Museum of Art. Cleveland, 1971, p. 3, mentions it with the Madonna and Child in the Pisa cathedral as the two works closest to Berlinghiero's signed crucifix in the Museo Nazionale di Villa Guinigi, Lucca.
Burton B. Fredericksen and Federico Zeri. Census of Pre-Nineteenth-Century Italian Paintings in North American Public Collections. Cambridge, Mass., 1972, pp. 26, 310, 609.
Eloise M. Angiola. "Nuovi documenti su Bonaventura e Marco di Berlinghiero." Prospettiva 21 (April 1980), p. 83, fig. 1, suggests dating it prior to 1236, by which time Berlinghiero had died.
Howard Hibbard. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1980, p. 216, fig. 387.
James H. Stubblebine. "Ugolino di Nerio: Old and New in an Early Madonna." Apollo 121 (June 1985), pp. 369, 372 n. 12, dates it about 1310 (likely a misprint for 1210); compares it with the Madonna in a polyptych by Guido da Siena in the Pinacoteca Nazionale, Siena.
Antonino Caleca in La pittura in Italia: il Duecento e il Trecento. Ed. Enrico Castelnuovo. Milan, 1986, vol. 1, p. 234; vol. 2, p. 558, dates it to the first twenty years of the thirteenth century, suggesting that during this time Berlinghiero was trained in the circle of the masters of the Calci Bible.
Luiz C. Marques. La peinture du Duecento en Italie centrale. Paris, 1987, pp. 72–74. fig. 83, dates it about 1210–30, and notes the influence of Berlinghiero on the Master of Bigallo
Roberta Ferrazza. Palazzo Davanzati e le collezioni di Elia Volpi. Florence, 1993, pp. 128–29, fig. 129, mentions it among the works formerly in the Volpi collection, Florence.
Miklós Boskovits. A Critical and Historical Corpus of Florentine Painting. Vol. 1, section 1, The Origins of Florentine Painting: 1100–1270. new ed. Florence, 1993, pp. 54, 339, 801, fig. 32, ascribes it to an anonymous Pisan painter, active about 1200, known as the Master of the San Matteo Crucifix, the author of a large painted crucifix from the monastery of San Matteo, now in the Museo Nazionale, Pisa.
Hans Belting. Likeness and Presence: A History of the Image before the Era of Art. Chicago, 1994, pp. 365, 593 n. 60, fig. 221 [German ed., 1990, pp. 408, 657 n. 59, fig. 221], analyzes the gestures of the Mother and Child and suggests that Berlighiero modeled it on contemporary Byzantine works.
Filippo Todini and Patrick Matthiesen in Gold Backs, 1250–1480. Exh. cat., Matthiesen Fine Art. London, 1996, pp. 35, 37 n. 4, fig. 2, compares it with a Madonna and Child in the Matthiesen Gallery, London.
Rebecca W. Corrie in The Glory of Byzantium. Ed. Helen C. Evans and William D. Wixom. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1997, p. 486–87, no. 321, ill. (color), discusses the imitation of Byzantine art in thirteenth-century Italy, and notes that the half-length Hodegetria type was common in Tuscany at the time.