"The Fine Arts: The French Impressionists." Critic 5 (April 17, 1886), p. 195.
Georges Grappe. Edgar Degas. Berlin, , ill. p. 53.
Julius Meier-Graefe. Entwicklungsgeschichte der Modernen Kunst. Vol. 2, 2nd ed. Munich, 1915, pl. 254.
Paul Lafond. Degas. Vol. 1, Paris, 1918, ill. p. 50, erroneously as still in the collection of Durand-Ruel.
Paul Jamot. "Degas (1834–1917)." Gazette des beaux-arts, 4th ser., 14 (April–June 1918), pp. 162–63.
Paul Lafond. Degas. Vol. 2, Paris, 1919, p. 25, refers to the version in the Victoria and Albert Museum, London as one of Degas's first pictures of dancers onstage, calling ours "a less well known variant"; identifies portraits of the collector Helch [sic for Albert Hecht] and the vicomte Lepic in the London picture
Henri Hertz. Degas. Paris, 1920, pp. 96–97, discusses the differences in execution between the dancers and the musicians and spectators.
Julius Meier-Graefe. Degas. Munich, 1920, pp. 31–32, pl. 14 [English ed., 1923, pp. 46–47, pl. XIV], confuses it with the London version; criticizes the differences in execution between the upper and lower portions of the composition, asserting that "it would not be unreasonable to suspect the work of two different artists in this picture" and calls the ballet onstage "an arbitrary background"; mentions the influence of Adolf Menzel on Degas's theater scenes.
Royal Cortissoz. "Modern France and Renaissance Italy: A Masterpiece by Degas and a Sienese Ceiling." New York Tribune (January 30, 1921), p. 7.
Iakov Tugendkhol'd. Edgar Degas. Moscow, 1922, ill. p. 44.
Paul Jamot. Degas. Paris, 1924, p. 98 n. 1, p. 138, calls it "less advanced" in execution compared to the London version, which he states was the picture shown in Durand-Ruel's 1872 London exhibition; erroneously locates our picture as having been in the collection of Mme Albert Hecht [see Refs. Callen 1971 and Distel 1981].
Paul Jamot. "Deux tableaux de Degas acquis par les Musées nationaux: l'Orchestre et le portrait de Mademoiselle Dihau." Le Figaro artistique (January 3, 1924), pp. 2–4, ill., as in the collection of Mme Hecht.
Basil S. Long. Catalogue of the Constantine Alexander Ionides Collection. Vol. 1, Paintings in Oil, Tempera and Water-colour together with certain of the Drawings. London, 1925, p. 19, calls it another version of the London picture, belonging to Madame Hecht.
J. B. Manson. The Life and Work of Edgar Degas. London, 1927, p. 19, calls it "slightly different and less satisfactory" than the London version.
Arsène Alexandre. "La collection Havemeyer, 2e Étude: Degas." La Renaissance 12 (October 1929), p. 484, ill. opp. p. 479.
"The H. O. Havemeyer Collection." Parnassus 2 (March 1930), p. 7, calls it Degas's personal interpretation of Daumier.
H. O. Havemeyer Collection: Catalogue of Paintings, Prints, Sculpture and Objects of Art. n.p., 1931, pp. 106–7, ill.
Louise Burroughs. "Degas in the Havemeyer Collection." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 27 (May 1932), p. 144, notes that Dihau was the inspiration for the London version, of which our painting is a variation.
Independent Painters of Nineteenth Century Paris. Exh. cat., Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Boston, 1935, pp. 15–16, no. 12, identifies portraits of Dihau, Albert Hecht, and Vicomte Lepic in our picture [Lepic appears only in the London version; see Refs. Lafond 1919, Pantazzi 1988].
Camille Mauclair. Degas. London, , pl. 160, confuses it with the London version.
Agnes Mongan. "Degas as Seen in American Collections." Burlington Magazine 72 (June 1938), p. 296.
Hans Huth. "Impressionism Comes to America." Gazette des beaux-arts, 6th ser., 29 (April 1946), p. 239 n. 22, states that either this picture or the London version was included in the American Art Association Impressionist exhibition [Exh. New York 1886].
John Rewald. The History of Impressionism. New York, 1946, ill. p. 231.
P[aul]. A[ndré]. Lemoisne. Degas et son œuvre. [reprint 1984]. Paris, [1946–49], vol. 1, p. 68; vol. 2, pp. 144–45, no. 294, ill., identifies the figure with the opera glasses as Albert Hecht and the figure to his left in the orchestra as Dihau.
Lillian Browse. Degas Dancers. New York, , pp. 22, 28, 52, 66, 337–38, pl. 8, observes that whereas in "The Orchestra of the Opéra" (about 1870; Musée d'Orsay, Paris; L186), the dancers onstage serve as background to the group portrait of the orchestra, in this picture the composition is more evenly divided; states that it depicts the third act, the "Ballet of the Nuns," danced by Laure Fonta in the 1871 production of the opera; reproduces three studies of the dancers (Victoria and Albert Museum, London) and notes that Faure commissioned the second version after seeing this picture.
François Fosca. Degas. Geneva, 1954, p. 43.
Douglas Cooper. The Courtauld Collection. London, 1954, p. 60, remarks that since this picture is dated 1872, it must be the version exhibited at Durand-Ruel, London during that year, noting that the London variant was not finished until 1876.
Pierre Cabanne. Edgar Degas. Paris, , pp. 31–32, 97, 109, under no. 38 [English ed., 1958, pp. 31–32, 97, 110, under no. 38].
Jean Sutherland Boggs. "Degas Notebooks at the Bibliothèque Nationale III: Group C (1863–1886)." Burlington Magazine 100 (July 1958), pp. 243–44, records studies for this picture as well as notes about the stage set and lighting effects in a notebook dating from about 1872 in the Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris.
Jean S. Boggs. An Exhibition of Works by Edgar Hilaire Germain Degas, 1834–1917. Exh. cat., Los Angeles County Museum. Los Angeles, 1958, p. 14.
Peter A. Wick. "Degas' Violinist." Bulletin of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston 57, no. 310 (1959), p. 90.
Louisine W. Havemeyer. Sixteen to Sixty: Memoirs of a Collector. New York, 1961, p. 263.
John Rewald. The History of Impressionism. rev., enl. ed. New York, 1961, pp. 273–75, ill., notes that this picture must have been purchased immediately after its completion by Durand-Ruel since he exhibited it in the winter of 1872 [the exhibition was in the summer of 1872].
Ronald Pickvance. "Degas's Dancers: 1872–6." Burlington Magazine 105 (June 1963), p. 258, comments that with this picture, "The Orchestra of the Opéra" (Orsay), and "Orchestra Musicians" (about 1870–71, reworked about 1874–76; Städelsches Kunstinstitut und Städtische Galerie, Frankfurt; L295) Degas began to focus on the grouping of figures in an interior, although he concentrated more on the elements of portraiture and artificial light.
Geoffrey Agnew. "A Ballet Scene by Degas." Listener 72 (December 10, 1964), pp. 944–45.
Jonathan Mayne. "Degas's Ballet Scene from 'Robert le Diable'." Victoria and Albert Museum Bulletin 2 (October 1966), pp. 150–52, 155, fig. 2, states that Hecht was the first owner of this picture after Durand-Ruel; compares it to the London version, noting that in ours the portraits of the orchestra members take precedence over the ballet scene onstage.
Charles Sterling and Margaretta M. Salinger. French Paintings: A Catalogue of the Collection of The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Vol. 3, XIX–XX Centuries. New York, 1967, pp. 66–69, ill., suggest the influence of Menzel's "At the Gymnase Theater" (1856; Nationalgalerie, Berlin), a Daumier lithograph (1852), and the Daumier painting "The Melodrama" (1856–58; Neue Pinakothek, Munich).
Lillian Browse. "Degas's Grand Passion." Apollo 85 (February 1967), p. 105.
Ronald Pickvance. Degas: Pastels and Drawings. Exh. cat., Nottingham University Art Gallery. Nottingham, 1969, unpaginated, under nos. 14, 15.
Fiorella Minervino in L'opera completa di Degas. Milan, 1970, pp. 99, 109, no. 290, ill.
Anthea Callen. "Jean-Baptiste Faure, 1830–1914: A Study of a Patron and Collector of the Impressionists and their Contemporaries." Master's thesis, University of Leicester, 1971, pp. 158–59, 162, no. 192, states that although Hecht has been recorded as the original owner, this picture was owned by Durand-Ruel almost immediately after its completion in 1872 when it was exhibited in London; considers it likely that Faure bought it from Durand-Ruel in 1874, the same year that he commissioned the second version.
Theodore Reff. "Degas's 'Tableau de Genre'." Art Bulletin 54 (September 1972), p. 319 n. 33, p. 329.
C. M. Kauffmann. Catalogue of Foreign Paintings. London, 1973, vol. 2, p. 24, under no. 58, states that it was painted for Hecht.
Theodore Reff. Degas, The Artist's Mind. [New York], 1976, pp. 221, 327 n. 33, p. 329 n. 88.
Theodore Reff. The Notebooks of Edgar Degas: A Catalogue of the Thirty-Eight Notebooks in the Bibliothèque Nationale and Other Collections. Oxford, 1976, vol. 1, p. 7 n. 2, pp. 9, 21, 119–20 (notebook 24, pp. 7, 9–11, 13, 15–17, 19–21), catalogues several studies and notes for this picture (reproduced vol. 1, pl. 29; vol. 2, notebook 24, pp. 9–11, 13, 15–17, 19); annotates Degas's note about the "tête de Georges en silhouette" as a reference to the conductor Georges Hainl.
Theodore Reff. "Degas: A Master among Masters." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 34 (Spring 1977), p. , fig. 46 (color).
Theodore Reff. "Edgar Degas and the Dance." Arts Magazine 53 (November 1978), p. 149, mentions it as Degas's only ballet picture where the dancers are not wearing tutus.
Marc Saul Gerstein. "Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Fans." PhD diss., Harvard University, 1978, p. 27.
Charles S. Moffett. Degas: Paintings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1979, pp. 7, 9–10, colorpl. 13.
Ian Dunlop. Degas. New York, 1979, p. 230 n. 22.
Eugénie de Keyser. Degas: Réalité et métaphore. Louvain-la-Neuve, 1981, p. 60.
Jacques Dufwa. Winds from the East: A Study in the Art of Manet, Degas, Monet and Whistler 1856–86. Stockholm, 1981, pp. 99, 102, 205 n. 48, calls the London version a free copy of ours.
Frances Weitzenhoffer. "The Creation of the Havemeyer Collection, 1875–1900." PhD diss., City University of New York, 1982, p. 315 n. 32.
Anne Distel. "Albert Hecht, collectionneur (1842–1889)." Bulletin de la Société de l'Histoire de l'Art Français, année 1981, (1983), p. 272 n. 5, suggests this picture was inscribed 1872 at the time of its sale to Durand-Ruel in January of that year, but that it may have been included in an 1871 exhibition on rue Lafitte as "Orchestra of the Opéra" [see Ref. Loyrette 1988]; argues that it could not have been owned by Hecht and provides detailed provenance history; identifies the figure with opera glasses as more closely resembling Hecht's brother, Henri and suggests that Albert may have inspired Degas to paint the picture.
Suzanne Folds McCullagh in Degas in The Art Institute of Chicago. Exh. cat., Art Institute of Chicago. Chicago, 1984, p. 72.
George T. M. Shackelford. Degas: The Dancers. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Art. Washington, 1984, pp. 23–24, 26–27, 41 n. 14, pp. 77, 130, no. 2, ill. pp. 23, 150 (overall and detail), discusses it as one of several genre portraits of opera scenes which focus on the musicians and spectators rather than the dancers onstage.
Sue Welsh Reed Barbara Stern Shapiro in Edgar Degas: The Painter as Printmaker. Exh. cat., Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Boston, 1984, p. 68.
Charles S. Moffett. Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Paintings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1985, pp. 55, 68–69, 250, ill. in color (overall and detail).
Götz Adriani. Degas: Pastels, Oil Sketches, Drawings. Exh. cat., Kunsthalle Tübingen. New York, 1985, pp. 54, 360, under no. 84, ill. p. 359.
Martine Kahane. Robert le Diable. Exh. cat., Théâtre National de l'Opéra de Paris. Paris, 1985, p. 66.
Frances Weitzenhoffer. The Havemeyers: Impressionism Comes to America. New York, 1986, p. 130.
Eunice Lipton. Looking into Degas: Uneasy Images of Women and Modern Life. Berkeley, 1986, p. 76.
Ann Dumas. Degas's 'Mlle. Fiocre' in Context: A Study of 'Portrait de Mlle. E. F. . . ; à propos du ballet "La Source"'. Brooklyn, 1988, p. 43, remarks that in this picture and "The Orchestra of the Opéra" (Orsay) Degas "exposes and even parodies" the illusionism of the theatrical performance.
Gary Tinterow in Degas. Exh. cat., Galeries Nationales du Grand Palais, Paris. New York, 1988, pp. 384, 431.
Michael Pantazzi in Degas. Exh. cat., Galeries Nationales du Grand Palais, Paris. New York, 1988, pp. 221–23, 269–70, 272, suggests that Faure bought it in 1887 because he regretted selling the second version; identifies this picture as the one Degas refers to in an 1872 letter to James Tissot, lamenting that "certain parts of my 'Orchestre' are not done well enough"; remarks that Degas did not rework it because he was able to revise the composition in the second version commissioned by Faure; interprets Degas's notes on the set and lighting effects as having been made after completing our version [see Ref. Reff 1976, Notebooks]; disagrees with comparisons to Menzel's "At the Gymnase Theater" (Nationalgalerie, Berlin).
Henri Loyrette in Degas. Exh. cat., Galeries Nationales du Grand Palais, Paris. New York, 1988, pp. 59, 171–74, no. 103, ill. (color), dates it 1871 since it was bought by Durand-Ruel in January 1872; considers the identification of the figure with opera glasses as Albert Hecht "not without basis," noting that x-rays reveal that his figure was added later to the canvas; remarks that the spectators are not interested in watching the ballet because this opera was so regularly performed that it had become "a well-worn museum piece".
Richard Thomson. "The Degas Exhibition at the Grand Palais." Burlington Magazine 130 (April 1988), p. 296.
Jean Sutherland Boggs in Degas. Exh. cat., Galeries Nationales du Grand Palais, Paris. New York, 1988, p. 487.
Henri Loyrette. "Degas à l'Opéra." Degas inédit: Actes du Colloque Degas. Paris, 1989, p. 57.
Anne Distel. Impressionism: The First Collectors. New York, 1990, pp. 72, 90.
Henri Loyrette. Degas. Paris, 1991, p. 612.
Barbara Stern Shapiro et. al. Pleasures of Paris: Daumier to Picasso. Exh. cat., Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Boston, 1991, pp. 114–15, 185, no. 94, ill. (color), dates it 1871–72.
John House. "Degas' 'Tableaux de Genre'." Dealing with Degas: Representations of Women and the Politics of Vision. Ed. Richard Kendall and Griselda Pollock. London, 1992, p. 81, asserts that a female figure is implied by the gaze of the man holding opera glasses, commenting that "in a stock situation like this, woman's role as object of this gaze is so passive, so taken for granted that the female figure need not appear at all".
Deborah Bershad. "Looking, Power and Sexuality: Degas' 'Woman with a Lorgnette'." Dealing with Degas: Representations of Women and the Politics of Vision. Ed. Richard Kendall and Griselda Pollock. London, 1992, p. 101, compares the device of the man with opera glasses to that used by Cassatt in "At the Opera" (1878; Museum of Fine Arts, Boston) and Renoir in "The Loge" (1874; Courtauld Institute of Art Gallery, London).
Louisine W. Havemeyer. Sixteen to Sixty: Memoirs of a Collector. Ed. Susan Alyson Stein. 3rd ed. [1st ed. 1930, repr. 1961]. New York, 1993, pp. 257, 263, 337 n. 376, p. 339 n. 394.
Susan Alyson Stein in Splendid Legacy: The Havemeyer Collection. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1993, pp. 222, 286.
Gary Tinterow in Splendid Legacy: The Havemeyer Collection. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1993, pp. 8, 49, 53 n. 68, colorpl. 7.
Gretchen Wold in Splendid Legacy: The Havemeyer Collection. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1993, pp. 326–27, no. A202, ill.
Jean Sutherland Boggs in Degas Portraits. Exh. cat., Kunsthaus Zürich. London, 1994, p. 52.
Gary Tinterow in La collection Havemeyer: Quand l'Amérique découvrait l'impressionnisme. Exh. cat., Musée d'Orsay. Paris, 1997, pp. 18, 33, 78 n. 97, p. 104, no. 5, ill. p. 34 (color), dates it 1871–72.
Eberhard Roters. Malerei des 19. Jahrhunderts: Themen und Motive. Cologne, 1998, vol. 1, pp. 379–80, ill.
Andreas Blühm and Louise Lippincott. Light! The Industrial Age 1750–1900: Art & Science, Technology & Society. Exh. cat., Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam. London, 2000, pp. 167, 245, ill. (color), date it 1871 in the caption and 1871–72 in the checklist.
Jill DeVonyar and Richard Kendall. Degas and the Dance. Exh. cat., Detroit Institute of Arts. New York, 2002, pp. 6, 14, 34–35, 52, 54–55, 58, 93, 95, 107, 158, 165, 281 n. 121, p. 285 n. 6, p. 289, colorpl. 53, propose that Degas may have begun this picture as early as 1870; suggest that Elise Parent, who danced the role of the Mother Superior, posed for the figures of the dancers and that Albert Hecht was included in the picture because Degas hoped to cultivate him as a patron; observe that by depicting this frequently produced standard from the Opéra repertory during a time when a new opera house was near completion, Degas instills the picture with the "burden of nostalgia".
Karen Wilkin. "Bodies of Knowledge." Art in America 91 (March 2003), p. 96.
Madeleine Korn. "Exhibitions of Modern French Art and Their Influence on Collectors in Britain 1870–1918: The Davies Sisters in Context." Journal of the History of Collections 16, no. 2 (2004), pp. 193–94, 205 n. 24, p. 207, fig. 1, dates it 1872.
Belinda Thomson et. al. Gauguin's Vision. Exh. cat., Royal Scottish Academy Building. Edinburgh, 2005, pp. 56, 123, colorpl. 62, compares its composition to that of Gauguin's "Vision of the Sermon: Jacob Wrestling with the Angel" (1888; National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh).
Jill DeVonyar in Annette Dixon. The Dancer: Degas, Forain, Toulouse-Lautrec. Exh. cat., Portland Art Museum. Portland, Oreg., 2008, pp. 209, 211, 233 n. 36, fig. 9 (color).
Jane Kinsman. Degas: The Uncontested Master. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Australia. Canberra, 2008, pp. 114, 122–23, 267, no. 48, ill. (color), calls it "The Ballet of 'Robert le Diable'".
Michael Pantazzi in Jane Kinsman. Degas: The Uncontested Master. Exh. cat., National Gallery of Australia. Canberra, 2008, pp. 247–48.
Jill DeVonyar and Richard Kendall. Degas & Music. Exh. cat., Hyde Collection. Glens Falls, N. Y., 2009, p. 65.
Ann Dumas in Drama and Desire: Art and Theatre from the French Revolution to the First World War. Ed. Guy Cogeval and Beatrice Avanzi. Exh. cat., Musée Cantini, Marseilles. Milan, 2010, pp. 263, 267, fig. 5 (color).
Sandra Gianfreda. "The early 'Japonistes'." Monet, Gauguin, Van Gogh . . . "Japanese Inspirations" Museum Folkwang. Exh. cat., Museum Folkwang, Essen. Göttingen, 2014, pp. 63, 338 n. 32.
Isabelle Gaëtan and Monique Nonne in Inventing Impressionism: Paul Durand-Ruel and the Modern Art Market. Ed. Sylvie Patry. Exh. cat., Musée du Luxembourg, Paris. London, 2015, p. 212 [French ed., "Paul Durand-Ruel : le Pari de l'Impressionnisme," Paris, 2014, p. 197].
Anne Robbins in Inventing Impressionism: Paul Durand-Ruel and the Modern Art Market. Ed. Sylvie Patry. Exh. cat., Musée du Luxembourg, Paris. London, 2015, pp. 180, 240, 283 n. 97 [French ed., "Paul Durand-Ruel: le Pari de l'Impressionnisme," Paris, 2014, pp. 141, 165, 224 n. 94].
Colin B. Bailey. "How He Ruled Art." New York Review of Books 62 (December 3, 2015), p. 63.