Théodore Duret. Histoire d'Édouard Manet et de son œuvre. Paris, 1902, p. 219, no. 106, lists it under 1866–68, calls it a sketch, and places it in the collection of M. Ménard-Dorian, Paris.
Étienne Moreau-Nélaton. Manuscrit de l'œuvre d'Édouard Manet, peinture et pastels. , unpaginated, no. 107 [Département des Estampes, Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris].
Théodore Duret. Manet and the French Impressionists. 2nd ed. [1st ed. 1910]. London, 1912, p. 229, no. 106.
Étienne Moreau-Nélaton. Manet raconté par lui-même. Paris, 1926, vol. 1, p. 109, fig. 118, dates it about 1869.
Exposition rétrospective d'art français. Exh. cat., Musée de l'État [Rijksmuseum]. Amsterdam, 1926, p. 51, no. 67, calls it unfinished and dates it about 1868.
A. Tabarant. Manet, histoire catalographique. Paris, 1931, pp. 161–62, no. 121.
Paul Jamot and Georges Wildenstein. Manet. Paris, 1932, vol. 1, pp. 133–34, no. 135; vol. 2, fig. 55, date it 1866 and erroneously list it as no. 14 in the 1867 Manet exhibition at the Place de l'Alma.
Exhibition of Modern French Painting, From Manet to Matisse. Exh. cat., Art Gallery of Toronto. Toronto, 1933, p. 7, no. 22, dates it 1869.
Exhibition of Paintings by the Master Impressionists. Exh. cat., Durand-Ruel. New York, 1934, unpaginated, no. 8, dates it 1869.
A.[lfred] M. F.[rankfurter]. "Paintings by the Impressionists Recently Added to American Collections: Part I." Art News 34 (May 23, 1936), pp. 5–6, ill., dates it about 1869.
Harry B. Wehle. "A Loan of Paintings." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 31 (October 1936), p. 209.
Robert Rey. Manet. English ed. [French ed. 1938]. New York, 1938, p. 162, no. 62, ill., dates it 1866.
A. Tabarant. Manet et ses œuvres. 4th ed. (1st. ed. 1942). Paris, 1947, pp. 129–30, 536, no. 124, fig. 124, dates it 1866 and notes that Jamot and Wildenstein [Ref. 1932] erroneously include it in the 1867 exhibition.
Harry B. Wehle. "The de Groot Collection." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 6 (June 1948), p. 270, ill., includes it in the 1867 Avenue de l'Alma exhibition.
Masterpieces from the Collection of Adelaide Milton de Groot. Exh. cat., Perls Galleries. New York, 1958, unpaginated, no. 2, fig. 2, dates it about 1867.
Sandra Orienti in The Complete Paintings of Manet. New York, 1967, p. 96, no. 108, ill., dates it 1866.
Denis Rouart and Daniel Wildenstein. Édouard Manet, catalogue raisonné. Paris, 1975, vol. 1, pp. 112–13, no. 117, ill., date it 1866; do not include it in the Avenue de l'Alma Exhibition of 1867.
Charles S. Moffett in Manet, 1832–1883. Ed. Françoise Cachin and Charles S. Moffett. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1983, pp. 331, 426, 441 [French ed., Paris, 1983, pp. 331, 442], states that "technical evidence indicates that Manet began to paint her face . . . and scraped it off three times before finally abandoning" this portrait.
Charles S. Moffett. Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Paintings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1985, pp. 38–39, ill. (color), discusses the dating, noting that it recalls Manet's work of the late 1860s, but comments that the character of the brushwork is similar to "that of a much later but also unfinished picture, 'Le Clarion,' [Wildenstein & Co., New York] of 1882".
Gary Tinterow et al. Capolavori impressionisti dei musei americani. Exh. cat., Museo di Capodimonte, Naples. Milan, 1987, pp. 58–59, no. 24, ill. (color).
Roger Hurlburt. "Free Spirits." Sun-Sentinel (Fort Lauderdale) (December 20, 1992), p. 4D, suggests that "some critics believe another artist touched up the face to make the picture suitable for exhibit".
Vivien Perutz. Édouard Manet. Lewisburg, Pa., 1993, p. 79.
Beth Archer Brombert. Édouard Manet: Rebel in a Frock Coat. Boston, 1996, pp. 143, 207–9, 296, dates it 1866.
Andrea Kirsh and Rustin S. Levenson. Seeing Through Paintings: Physical Examination in Art Historical Studies. New Haven, 2000, p. 265.
Richard R. Brettell and Stephen F. Eisenman. Nineteenth-Century Art in the Norton Simon Museum. Ed. Sara Campbell. Vol. 1, New Haven, 2006, pp. 266–67, fig. 69c, date it about 1874–76.
Gary Tinterow in The Masterpieces of French Painting from The Metropolitan Museum of Art: 1800–1920. Exh. cat., Museum of Fine Arts, Houston. New York, 2007, pp. 88, 230, no. 60, ill. (color and black and white).