Filippo Giordano delle Lanze. Receipt. 1968, attributes it to Pompeo Batoni, as coming from the Merenda collection in Forlì.
Robert Enggass. Letter to Claus Virch. October 10, 1969, tentatively puts forward an attribution to Gaspare Traversi.
Robert Enggass. Letter to Claus Virch. October 11, 1969, confidently ascribes it to Gaspare Traversi.
Pierre Rosenberg. Letter to Claus Virch. May 27, 1970, as definitely not by Subleyras.
Federico Zeri. Letter to Everett Fahy. May 24, 1971, finds Robert Enggass's attribution to Gaspare Traversi "absolutely convincing" [see Refs. Enggass 1969]; recognizes "Traversi's types" in this picture, particularly in the faces of the angel and the saint.
Nicola Spinosa in Civiltà del '700 a Napoli, 1734–1799. Exh. cat., Museo Nazionale di Capodimonte, Naples. Florence, 1979, vol. 1, pp. 228–29, ill., publishes this picture for the first time; calls it one of Traversi's masterpieces from around 1758, the period in which he executed his "Pentecost" for San Pietro d'Alcantara, Parma; believes this painting, like the Pentecost, was executed in Rome and then sent to Emilia Romagna; admires Traversi's "brilliant palette" and the "intensely expressive quality of his faces"; comments on the unusual iconography of the scene, which infuses the picture with a sense of reality; identifies the child at Saint Margaret's side as "her curly-haired daughter".
Ferdinando Bologna. Gaspare Traversi nell'illuminismo europeo. Naples, 1980, pp. 84–85, accepts the attribution to Traversi; sees in this picture visual evidence of Traversi's relationship with Benefial in Rome, noting in particular the influence of his 1756 "Portrait of the Marefoschi Family" [Galleria Corsini, Rome] on Traversi.
Nicola Spinosa in The Golden Age of Naples: Art and Civilization Under the Bourbons, 1734–1805. Exh. cat., Detroit Institute of Arts. 1, Detroit, 1981, pp. 148–49, no. 50, ill., cites it as "an outstanding example" of Traversi's Roman work of about 1758; compares it to his 1758 "Pentecost" for San Pietro d'Alcantara, Parma, and believes that this picture, like the "Pentecost," was probably sent to a church in the district of Parma; comments on the "unusual iconography selected by the artist in order to infuse the scene with a sense of reality".
Franz Schulze. "Vintage Bourbon." Art in America (December 1981), p. 111, questions the attribution to Traversi, noting that this picture with "its subdued lighting and bland forms. . . bears little clear relation to Traversi's customary spastic compositions and boisterous chiaroscuro".
Nicola Spinosa. Pittura napoletana del Settecento: dal Rococò al Classicismo. Naples, 1987, pp. 67, 108–9, no. 101, ill. (color), dates it about 1758 and comments on its relationship to Benefial's 1756 "Portrait of the Marefoschi Family"; compares the theme of our picture to that of a Franciscan saint represented in one of Traversi's altarpieces for the Convent of Castellarquato (now in the Cathedral of Parma); despite documentary evidence to the contrary, believes this picture was originally executed for a Franciscan church in Emilia Romagna in to conjunction with his other works for Castellarquato; notes stylistic affinities with Traversi's pictures executed for the Monastic Order of Saint Francis and Padre Raffaello de' Rossi in Lugano, suggesting that Padre Raffaello may also have been the patron of this work.
Giancarlo Sestieri UTET. La pittura del Settecento. Turin, 1988, pp. 101–2, ill., considers this picture the "apex" of Traversi's religious works, noting in particular that his use of Seicento "naturalism" makes a sacred theme modern.
Nicola Spinosa in La pittura in Italia: il Settecento. 2nd ed. Milan, 1990, vol. 2, p. 480, ill. (color).
Francesco Barocelli. "The Painter in the Drawing-room: Gaspare Traversi." FMR no. 70 (October 1994), pp. 91–92, ill., suggests this picture may date to the end of Traversi's career; regards it as "one of the most fascinating and problematic paintings of the century. . . a scene of desolating poverty, brightened by the saint's decision to repent".
Eliot W. Rowlands. The Collections of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art: Italian Paintings, 1300–1800. Kansas City, Mo., 1996, pp. 437, 442, dates this picture about 1760, noting its indebtedness to Subleyras and a trend toward "softer forms, stabler compositions, and a more meditative mood".
Francesco Barocelli in Gaspare Traversi: napoletani del '700 tra miseria e nobiltà. Exh. cat., Castel Sant'Elmo. Naples, 2003, pp. 71, 90–91, 240, 257, nos. 7, R94, ill. (overall in color and black and white, color detail), dates it about 1758, after Traversi had absorbed the stylistic influences of Subleyras and Benefial; identifies it with a picture of this subject listed in an 1805 inventory for the Convento sopresso dei M. Riformati di Castell' Arquato and suggests that the patron was the Minister General Rafaele da Lugagnano; discusses French influences on the picture.
Francesco Barocelli in Luce sul Settecento: Gaspare Traversi e l'arte del suo tempo in Emilia. Exh. cat., Galleria Nazionale. Naples, 2004, pp. 86–87, 236, 253, nos. 13, R94, ill. (color and black and white), [see Ref. Barocelli 2003].
Pierre Rosenberg. Only in America: One Hundred Paintings in American Museums Unmatched in European Collections. Milan, 2006, pp. 136–37, 236, ill. (color).