Albert Rosenthal, Philadelphia, 1917; sale, American Art Association, Plaza Hotel, New York, 22-23 Apr. 1920, no. 150; Frank Bulkeley Smith, Worcester, Massachusetts; William Randolph Hearst, San Simeon, California, 1920–died 1951; with Kennedy Galleries, New York, by 1965; Mrs. John C. Newington, Greenwich, Connecticut, by 1965
