[ Frédéric Spitzer d. 1890 , Paris ] ; Sir Thomas Gibson Carmichael, 12th Baronet of Castle Craig (sold 1902) ; Christie, Mason and Woods , London (May 12, 1902, lot 58) ; M. Brauer (1902–?) ; Sir Samuel Montagu, first Baron Swaythling 1832-1911 , London (sold 1924) ; Christie, Mason and Woods , London (May 8, 1924, lot 91) ; Alfred Spero (1924–?) ; [ Giorgio Sangiorgi , Rome (sold 1926)] ; [ Brummer Gallery (Paris and New York (1926–sold 1927)] ; William Randolph Hearst American, 1863–1951 , New York and San Simeon, CA (from 1927) ; International Studio Corporation , New York (owned W. R. Hearst, sold 1940) ; [ Brummer Gallery , Paris and New York (1940–sold 1947)]