New York. American Academy of Fine Arts. "Italian, Flemish, Spanish, Dutch, French, and English Pictures . . . Brought to this Country by Mr. Richard Abraham . . . .," March 1830, no. 51 (as "A Finished Sketch," by Giovanni Battista Tiepolo).

New York. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. "Temporary Exhibition," April 1906, no. 33 (as "Triumph of Ferdinand III").

New York. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. "The Taste of the Seventies," April 2–September 10, 1946, no. 55.

Honolulu Academy of Arts. "Four Centuries of European Painting," December 8, 1949–January 29, 1950, no. 14.

Art Gallery of Toronto. "Fifty Paintings by Old Masters," April 21–May 21, 1950, no. 45.

Detroit Institute of Arts. "Thirty-Eight Great Paintings from The Metropolitan Museum of Art," October 2–October 28, 1951, no catalogue.

Art Gallery of Toronto. "Thirty-Eight Great Paintings from The Metropolitan Museum of Art," November 14–December 12, 1951, no catalogue.

City Art Museum of St. Louis. "Thirty-Eight Great Paintings from The Metropolitan Museum of Art," January 6–February 4, 1952, no catalogue.

Seattle Art Museum. "Thirty-Eight Great Paintings from The Metropolitan Museum of Art," March 1–June 30, 1952, no catalogue.

New York. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. "Oil Sketches by 18th Century Italian Artists from New York Collections," January 30–March 21, 1971, no. 31.

Udine. Villa Manin di Passariano. "Tiepolo," June 27–October 31, 1971, no. 57.

New York. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. "Venetian Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum," May 1–September 2, 1974, no catalogue.

Leningrad [St. Petersburg]. State Hermitage Museum. "100 Paintings from the Metropolitan Museum," May 22–July 27, 1975, no. 12.

Moscow. State Pushkin Museum. "100 Paintings from the Metropolitan Museum," August 28–November 2, 1975, no. 12.

Stuttgart. Württembergisches Landesmuseum. "Die Zeit der Staufer," March 26–June 5, 1977, no. 1041.

Hanover. Forum des Landesmuseums. "Venedigs Ruhm im Norden," December 3, 1991–February 2, 1992, no. 76.

Kunstmuseum Düsseldorf im Ehrenhof. "Venedigs Ruhm in Norden," February 16–April 26, 1992, no. 76.

Fort Worth. Kimbell Art Museum. "Giambattista Tiepolo: Master of the Oil Sketch," September 18–December 12, 1993, no. 41.

Residenz Würzburg. "Der Himmel auf Erden: Tiepolo in Würzburg," February 15–May 19, 1996, no. 12.

Paris. Petit Palais, Musée des Beaux Arts de la Ville de Paris. "Giambattista Tiepolo, 1696–1770," October 22, 1998–January 24, 1999, no. 61.

Martigny. Fondation Pierre Gianadda. "The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York: Chefs-d'œuvre de la peinture européenne," June 23–November 12, 2006, no. 5.

Barcelona. Museu Nacional d'Art de Catalunya. "Grandes maestros de la pintura europea de The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Nueva York: De El Greco a Cézanne," December 1, 2006–March 4, 2007, no. 3.

A Catalogue of Italian, Flemish, Spanish, Dutch, French, and English Pictures; which have been Collected in Europe and Brought to this Country by Mr. Richard Abraham, of New Bond Street, London. Exh. cat., American Academy of Fine Arts. New York, 1830, pp. 46–47, no. 51, as "A Finished Sketch," by Giovanni Battista Tiepolo; describes it as "the presentation of banners, after a conquest, to one of the Roman Emperors, who is seated on his throne under a triumphal arch, the grouping of the figures on each side of which, is admirable"; notes that it was formerly in the collection of J. Taylor, England.

Henry James. "The Metropolitan Museum's '1871 Purchase'." Atlantic Monthly (June 1872) [reprinted in John L. Sweeney, ed., "The Painter's Eye," London, 1956, p. 58], as by Giovanni Battista Tiepolo.

F[ritz von]. Harck. "Berichte und Mittheilungen aus Sammlungen und Museen, über staatliche Kunstpflege und Restaurationen, neue Funde: Aus amerikanischen Galerien." Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft 11 (1888), p. 73, questions the title "Triumph of Ferdinand III".

B[ernard]. Berenson. "Les peintures italiennes de New-York et de Boston." Gazette des beaux-arts, 3rd ser., 15 (March 1896), p. 203, calls it a good sketch for a ceiling.

Bernhard Berenson. The Venetian Painters of the Renaissance. 3rd ed. New York, 1897, p. 128.

Eduard Sack. Giambattista und Domenico Tiepolo: Ihr Leben und Ihre Werke. Hamburg, 1910, vol. 2, p. 227, no. 555, confuses it with 07.225.300, attributed to Giaquinto, formerly in the Museum's collection.

Morton H. Bernath. New York und Boston. Leipzig, 1912, p. 85, as the Triumph of Ferdinand III.

Joseph Breck. "Paintings and Drawings by Tiepolo in the Metropolitan Museum." Art in America 1 (January 1913), pp. 8, 11, fig. 3, points out that the subject is the investiture of Bishop Harold von Hochheim as Duke of Franconia by the Emperor Frederick I, and that the picture is a study for the fresco in the Kaisersaal of the Residenz in Würzburg; notes that the fresco is dated 1752, and dates the study about 1751–52.

Philip Hendy. The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum: Catalogue of the Exhibited Paintings and Drawings. Boston, 1931, pp. 358–59, calls it a pendant to the Wedding of Frederick I and Beatrice of Burgundy (Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, Boston), suggesting that Tiepolo may have painted the two sketches in Italy, before his arrival at Würzburg.

Arthur McComb. The Baroque Painters of Italy: An Introductory Historical Survey. Cambridge, Mass., 1934, p. 127.

Max Goering. Letter. April 1938, calls it a study for the Würzburg fresco and dates it about 1750.

Daniel Catton Rich. Loan Exhibition of Paintings, Drawings and Prints by the two Tiepolos: Giambattista and Giandomenico. Exh. cat., Art Institute of Chicago. 1938, pp. 13, 24, no. 19, calls it a repetition of, rather than a study for, the Würzburg fresco.

M[ax]. Goering in Allgemeines Lexikon der bildenden Künstler. 33, Leipzig, 1939, pp. 149, 153.

Harry B. Wehle. The Metropolitan Museum of Art: A Catalogue of Italian, Spanish, and Byzantine Paintings. New York, 1940, p. 282, ill.

Max Goering. "Wenig Bekannte und neu gefundene Werke von Giov. Batt. Tiepolo." Pantheon 17 (October–December 1944), p. 102, ill. p. 106, dates it 1751.

Harry B. Wehle. "Seventy-Five Years Ago." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 4 (April 1946), p. 201, ill. p. 206.

Antonio Morassi. G. B. Tiepolo: His Life and Work. London, 1955, p. 26.

Max H. Von Freeden and Carl Lamb. Das Meisterwerk des Giovanni Battista Tiepolo: Die Fresken der Würzburger Residenz. Munich, 1956, pp. 47, 113 n. 3, pl. 32, call it a preparatory study, not a repetition.

Michael Levey. The Eighteenth Century Italian Schools. London, 1956, pp. 103–4 nn. 9, 10, accepts the attribution to Giovanni Battista Tiepolo, but agrees with Rich [see Ref. 1938] that it is more likely to be a repetition than a preparatory sketch; suggests a connection to a work in the National Gallery depicting the marriage of Frederick I and Beatrice (no. 2100), which he attributes to Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo.

Paul Wescher. La prima Idea: Die Entwicklung der Ölskizze von Tintoretto bis Picasso. Munich, 1960, p. 50.

Antonio Morassi. A Complete Catalogue of the Paintings of G. B. Tiepolo. London, 1962, p. 33, fig. 316, dates it about 1751–52; calls it probably the first idea for the Würzburg fresco, and possibly the pendant to the Gardner picture.

Michael Levey. "Review of Ref. Morassi 1962." Art Bulletin 45 (September 1963), p. 293.

Anna Pallucchini in L'opera completa di Giambattista Tiepolo. Milan, 1968, p. 115, no. 199b, ill., calls it a sketch for the fresco.

Michael Levey. The Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century Italian Schools. London, 1971, pp. 236–37 n. 13.

Rodolfo Pallucchini. "Tiepolo a Passariano." Arte veneta 25 (1971), p. 336.

Günter Passavant. "Mostra del Tiepolo: Zur Ausstellung in der Villa Manin di Passariano." Kunstchronik 24 (December 1971), pp. 364–65, fig. 6.

Aldo Rizzi. "Dipinti." Mostra del Tiepolo. Exh. cat., Villa Manin di Passariano. [1], [Milan], [1971], p. 124, no. 57, ill.

Burton B. Fredericksen and Federico Zeri. Census of Pre-Nineteenth-Century Italian Paintings in North American Public Collections. Cambridge, Mass., 1972, pp. 196, 485, 605.

Roger Fry. Letters of Roger Fry. New York, 1972, vol. 1, p. 255 n. 1 to letter no. 177 (March 2, 1906), lists it among works included in the 1906 exhibition.

Federico Zeri with the assistance of Elizabeth E. Gardner. Italian Paintings: A Catalogue of the Collection of The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Venetian School. New York, 1973, pp. 55–56, pl. 60, state that "it is more than probable that it is the preparatory sketch painted shortly before" the fresco; consider the Gardner work a companion piece.

Philip Hendy. European and American Paintings in the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. Boston, 1974, p. 249, believes that the MMA and Gardner pictures were probably painted in Venice in 1749–50.

Francis Haskell. Rediscoveries in Art: Some Aspects of Taste, Fashion and Collecting in England and France. Ithaca, N.Y., 1976, p. 115.

Reiner Haussherr. Die Zeit der Staufer: Geschichte—Kunst—Kultur. Exh. cat., Württembergisches Landesmuseum. Stuttgart, 1977, vol. 1, pp. 742–43, no. 1041; vol. 2, fig. 696.

Frank Büttner. Giovanni Battista Tiepolo: Die Fresken in der Residenz zu Würzburg. Würzburg, 1980, pp. 12, 59, ill. p. 15, calls it a sketch for the fresco.

George Knox. Giambattista and Domenico Tiepolo: A Study and Catalogue Raisonné of the Chalk Drawings. 1, Oxford, 1980, vol. 1, pp. 41, 49 n. 9, p. 302, attributes the London, Gardner, and MMA pictures to Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo, and agrees with Levey [see Refs. 1956 and 1971] that none of them are true modellos; erroneously identifies the MMA and Gardner paintings with two works listed in the "Musée du Prince Youssoupoff," St. Petersburg, 1839, nos. 114 and 148, where they are attributed to Domenico [see email of January 30, 2002 in archive file].

Michael Levey. Giambattista Tiepolo: His Life and Art. New Haven, 1986, pp. 182–83, pl. 164, as "Homage to the Emperor"; calls it "somewhat puzzling as the original 'modello,' yet clearly from the hand of Giambattista Tiepolo himself"; notes that "Tiepolo seems to be recalling partly the 'Continence of Scipio' at the Villa Cordellina, and its preparatory sketch, and also aiming at an effect of much greater depth than he sought in the final fresco".

Aldo Rizzi. Giambattista Tiepolo: Disegni dai Civici Musei di Storia e Arte di Trieste. Exh. cat., Civico Museo Sartorio, Trieste. Milan, 1988, p. 26.

Georges Brunel. Tiepolo. [Paris], 1991, pp. 183–84.

Hans Werner Grohn in Venedigs Ruhm im Norden. Exh. cat., Forum des Landesmuseums Hannover. Hanover, 1991, pp. 240–41, no. 76, ill. (color).

Beverly Louise Brown. "Hannover and Düsseldorf: Venedigs Ruhm im Norden." Burlington Magazine 134 (April 1992), p. 274.

Beverly Louise Brown. Giambattista Tiepolo: Master of the Oil Sketch. Exh. cat., Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth. Milan, 1993, pp. 268–71, no. 41, ill. pp. 120 (color) and 268, believes that Tiepolo painted this sketch in Venice before seeing the space designated for the fresco, and that he added the two swags of green drapery later, presumably after seeing the existing stucco curtains that would frame his fresco.

Massimo Gemin and Filippo Pedrocco. Giambattista Tiepolo: i dipinti, opera completa. Venice, 1993, pp. 145, 424, no. 414a, ill.

George Knox. "Giambattista Tiepolo at Fort Worth." Apollo 139 (December 1993), p. 403.

Teresa Longyear. "Giambattista Tiepolo: The Energetic and Fluent Brush." Giambattista Tiepolo: Master of the Oil Sketch. Exh. cat., Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth. Milan, 1993, p. 67, fig. 39 (color detail).

Catherine Whistler. "Fort Worth: Tiepolo Oil Sketches." Burlington Magazine 135 (December 1993), p. 859.

Rodolfo Pallucchini. La pittura nel Veneto: il Settecento. 1, Milan, 1995, p. 439.

Keith Christiansen et al. in Giambattista Tiepolo, 1696–1770. Exh. cat., The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 1996, p. 310 n. 1 [Italian ed., "Giambattista Tiepolo, 1696–1996," Milan, 1996], believes that Tiepolo probably painted it in Venice, and disagrees with Brown [see Ref. 1993] that the curtains were added later.

Peter O. Krückmann in Der Himmel auf Erden: Tiepolo in Würzburg. Exh. cat., Residenz, Würzburg. Munich, 1996, vol. 1, pp. 83–84, no. 12, ill. (color).

Peter O. Krückmann. Heaven on Earth: Tiepolo, Masterpieces of the Würzburg Years. Munich, 1996, pp. 89–90, fig. 80 (color).

Keith Christiansen. "The Ca' Dolfin Tiepolos." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 55 (Spring 1998), pp. 7, 9, fig. 5 (color).

Stéphane Loire and José de Los Llanos in Giambattista Tiepolo, 1696–1770. Exh. cat., Petit Palais, Musée des Beaux Arts de la Ville de Paris. Paris, 1998, pp. 194, 196–97, 199–200, no. 61, ill. (color).

Rosella Mamoli Zorzi. "Tiepolo, Henry James, and Edith Wharton." Metropolitan Museum Journal 33 (1998), pp. 211–14, 227 nn. 14, 15, 27, fig. 1.

Rosella Mamoli Zorzi. "Tiepolo e gli scrittori angloamericani nell'Ottocento." Giambattista Tiepolo nel terzo centenario della nascita. Padua, 1998, vol. 1, pp. 338–39, 343 n. 21, p. 344 n. 28, discusses Henry James's unfavorable response to the work of Tiepolo, including this sketch [see Ref. 1872].

Katharine Baetjer. "Buying Pictures for New York: The Founding Purchase of 1871." Metropolitan Museum Journal 39 (2004), pp. 173, 182, 218–19, 244–45, appendix 1A no. 149, ill. p. 218 and figs. 25 and 35 (installation photograph).

Mary Sprinson de Jesús in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York: Chefs-d'œuvre de la peinture européenne. Exh. cat., Fondation Pierre Gianadda. Martigny, 2006, pp. 12, 44–46, no. 5, ill. (color) [Catalan ed., Barcelona, 2006, pp. 15, 30–33, no. 3, ill. (color, overall and details)].