TULLIO LOMBARDO’S ADAM
A Masterpiece Restored

Thomas P. Campbell, Director and CEO of the Metropolitan Museum, said: “We are proud to return this great Tullio sculpture to public view in a beautiful new gallery.  Our extraordinary conservators collaborated with a team of experts over 12 years to pursue this extremely challenging work.  The results of their care and innovation are stunning.”

The installation of this gallery was made possible by Assunta Sommella Peluso, Ignazio Peluso, Ada Peluso and Romano I. Peluso.

On the evening of October 6, 2002, the pedestal supporting Tullio Lombardo’s 15th-century marble Adam collapsed in The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Vélez Blanco Patio. The sculpture, which has been in the Museum’s permanent collection since 1936, was severely damaged. In the wake of the initial shock and distress over this accident, the Metropolitan Museum made a commitment to undertake a conservation project that would, to the fullest extent possible, return the statue to its original appearance. After 12 years of painstaking and pioneering conservation research and treatment, augmented by curatorial research, Tullio Lombardo’s restored masterpiece Adam will be unveiled in a new gallery specially created for this occasion. 

The Metropolitan Museum, renowned for the depth of its curatorial, conservation, and scientific resources, was able to embark on this uniquely challenging restoration project by assembling a team of skilled and dedicated conservators, scientists, engineers, and imaging experts from both inside and outside the Museum. Their analysis, testing, and treatment have yielded a beautifully restored statue.  The project has also resulted in significant advances in the field of sculpture conservation, which will be presented in this exhibition and in the 2014 volume of the Metropolitan Museum Journal.  

Tullio Lombardo came from a renowned northern Italian family of sculptors and architects. He carved Adam in the early 1490s for the tomb of Andrea Vendramin, doge of Venice. The monument is the most lavish of its kind, designed to resemble an ancient Roman triumphal arch, incorporating both classicizing and biblical reliefs and statuary. Tullio’s nude was inspired by idealizing ancient sculpture, but the sculptor subtly unbalanced Adam’s pose to show that he was not just God’s first perfect human being, but also the anxious victim of the Serpent’s wiles. Adam conveys the story of the Fall of Man, which with the images of Christ the Redeemer made him a suitable subject for a tomb monument. In this way, the memorial to an exemplary individual also meditates on humanity’s essential faults and its ability to overcome them. Adam originally stood in the niche to the left of Vendramin’s casket and effigy, which is now occupied by a helmeted warrior; a figure of Eve was meant for the other niche. 

The tomb was originally located in Santa Maria dei Servi, but was moved to the basilica of Santi Giovanni e Paolo in the 1810s, where it remains. By 1821, Adam had been taken off the monument and brought to the Vendramin Calergi palace. In 1844 the Duchess of Berry bought the palace and its contents, and Adam remained with her descendants until 1931. By then Adam was in Paris, where the banker Henry Pereire acquired it. His widow sold the sculpture to an art dealer in 1935, and the Museum purchased it the following year to much fanfare. Adam was displayed in several different Met galleries until the accident in 2002. 

On impact, Adam broke into 28 large pieces and hundreds of smaller fragments. Fortunately, the head, face, and torso were relatively unscathed in the fall. The arms, which bore the brunt of the impact, the lower legs, and the decorative tree trunk suffered major damage. From the outset, it was clear that the treatment of the broken sculpture would be a formidable project, posing an unusual series of challenges with little in the way of past practice to draw on. The conservators had to find a method that would limit handling of the sculpture and position the heavy fragments precisely without abrading the fresh, vulnerable break edges. The importance of Adam warranted critical evaluation of the use of pins and adhesives traditionally used by conservators and an investigation into less invasive and more reversible approaches. Historically, the reassembly of large-scale sculpture has relied on the use of multiple iron or steel pins, supplemented, more recently, by structural adhesives such as epoxies. Shortly after the accident, the Museum’s conservators, conservation scientists, and curators, supported by an outside team of materials scientists and engineers, began an unprecedented multidisciplinary collaboration to determine the best course of treatment for the sculpture. The methods developed from this effort ultimately provided a new model for best practices and standards in the conservation of large stone sculpture.  

Investigations began in 2003 with three-dimensional laser scanning of the major fragments. The laser scans led to a variety of research avenues including finite element analysis, a computer-based structural engineering investigation, which informed the team about the stresses and strains in the sculpture as well as the nature of the breaks. Extensive research and testing never before conducted on conservation materials was carried out to determine the best adhesives and pinning materials for the treatment. The innovative treatment of the sculpture followed, giving special attention to the use of mock-ups and empirical studies carried out in an effort to minimize handling of the fragile break surfaces on the sculpture. The fresh breaks to the Carrara marble posed several challenges to the conservators, and required them to diverge from traditional sculpture conservation techniques. For example, an external armature was developed that was sufficiently substantial to support the assembled sculpture without adhesive. The armature not only supported the sculpture during assembly but also served as the method of clamping the fragments once adhesive was applied. The related article in the Metropolitan Museum Journal summarizes the research, drilling and pinning techniques, and how the armature was conceived, constructed, and utilized.

Following the structural work, the sculpture was carefully cleaned to remove surface grime that had accumulated over the years. Areas of loss were filled and toned to match the surrounding marble. The final stages of the treatment transformed the appearance of this damaged work of art so that it can once again be appreciated as a masterpiece of Renaissance art.

Adam’s return to public view coincides with the inauguration of a new gallery for Venetian and northern Italian sculpture. Adam will be exhibited there alone and in the round for nearly eight months, accompanied by an in-depth account of its conservation on digital screens and text panels.  Afterward, Adam will become the focal point of this permanent gallery, in a niche inspired by its original location on the tomb monument.  It will be joined by highlights of the Met’s sculpture from this period, including Cristoforo Solari’s Saint Catherine of Alexandria, which was purchased with the new gallery in mind.

The new Venetian Sculpture Gallery, a perfect cube, was designed with Renaissance ideals of geometry and proportion in mind. A novel lighting scheme, suggesting the suffused light of a chapel, and a seat at the center of the space, will create a meditative environment and encourage sustained encounters with important sculptures.

The new Venetian Sculpture Gallery and its inaugural installation, Tullio Lombardo’s Adam: A Masterpiece Restored, were co-curated by Luke Syson, Iris and B. Gerald Cantor Chairman, and Peter Jonathan Bell, Assistant Curator, both of the Metropolitan Museum’s Department of European Sculpture and Decorative Arts. Designers were Michael Langley, Exhibition Design Manager; Mortimer Lebigre, Graphic Designer; and Clint Ross Coller and Richard Lichte, Lighting Design Managers, all of the Museum’s Design Department. 

The conservation process involved the expertise of a number of curators, conservators, scientists, engineers, and other specialists. Curatorial oversight was provided by Ian Wardropper, formerly the Met's Iris and B. Gerald Cantor Chairman of European Sculpture and Decorative Arts and currently Director of The Frick Collection; James David Draper, Henry R. Kravis Curator in the Museum's Department of European Sculpture and Decorative Arts; and Luke Syson. 

Conservator Carolyn Riccardelli of the Museum's Department of Objects Conservation was the principal conservator and worked on almost every aspect of the project, including structural work and fills. Michael Morris, an independent sculpture conservator, worked primarily on the structural portions of the project. Conservator Jack Soultanian, also from the Met's Department of Objects Conservation, was responsible for the cleaning and all surface integration. They worked under the supervision of Lawrence Becker, who until July 1 was the Sherman Fairchild Conservator in Charge of Objects Conservation. George Wheeler, a consulting scientist at the Museum, led the materials research related to the project. Ronald Street, Senior Manager of 3D Imaging, Molding, and Prototyping in the Merchandise Development and Planning Department at the Museum, created virtual models of the sculpture that contributed significantly to the engineering analysis and treatment. This team collaborated with an extensive group of scientists from Princeton University School of Engineering and engineers from Computer Aided Engineering Associates, Inc., Middlebury, Connecticut.

Three essays in the Metropolitan Museum Journal (Volume 49, 2014) will be devoted to Tullio Lombardo’s Adam, discussing the art historical context of the monumental nude sculpture (by Luke Syson and Valeria Cafà), the ancient sources Tullio turned to for inspiration (by Valeria Cafà), and the pioneering methods employed by the team of conservators and scientists over the course of the 12-year conservation project (by Carolyn Riccardelli, Jack Soultanian, Michael Morris, Lawrence Becker, George Wheeler, and Ronald Street).

The Journal, issued annually by the Museum, publishes original research by members of the Museum staff and other specialists, ranging from first-time investigations to critical reassessments of works in the collection. Volume 49 will be published by December 31 both in a softcover edition and online. The softcover edition ($75), distributed by the University of Chicago Press, will be available in the Met’s book store and can be ordered online at http://store.metmuseum.org. Subscription information for the softcover and online versions is available at http://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/journals/journal/met.html. The online version will be available for download at www.metmuseum.org/MetPublications. 

Education programs related to the installation will include: a lecture on Friday, November 14, 4:00-5:00, on “Tullio Lombardo: Adam, the Vendramin Tomb, and Venetian Sculpture of the High Renaissance” by independent art historian Anne Markham Schulz; a gallery talk on “Tullio Lombardo’s Adam: History and Conservation” by Peter Jonathan Bell, Carolyn Riccardelli, and Jack Soultanian on Friday, February 6, 2015, 10:30-11:30; and an interactive multi-media performance/installation in July by artist Reid Farrington in the Venetian Sculpture Gallery (details to follow). All are free with Museum admission.

 

Text, photographs, and video summarizing the research and treatment of the sculpture will be presented on screens within the installation Tullio Lombardo’s Adam: A Masterpiece Restored in the new Venetian Sculpture Gallery.

A special feature on the Museum’s website, www.metmuseum.org/adamrestored, also provides information about the sculpture in various digital formats, including an eight-minute video describing the conservation process through the voices of the principal project participants; a digital animation illustrating the order of assembly of the fragments; and a video of time-lapse photography taken during assembly and cleaning.

The exhibition will also be featured on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter via the hashtag #AdamRestored.