Art/ Collection/ Art Object

Portrait of a Woman

Johann Nikolaus Grooth (German, 1723?–1797)
Oil on canvas
32 x 25 5/8 in. (81.3 x 65.1 cm)
Credit Line:
Gift of Édouard Jonas, 1922
Accession Number:
Not on view

The Artist: Grooth was born in Stuttgart in 1721 or 1723 to the Württemberg court painter and composer Johann Christoph Grooth. Like his artist brothers (see MMA 1978.554.2), he trained under his father and was able to study the old masters directly in the electoral gallery in Ludwigsburg, in which collection he was also active as a restorer. After working briefly for the elector of Bavaria in Munich (1757–58), he moved to Switzerland about 1759 and became a successful portrait painter in Basel and Bern. In 1771 he restored paintings by Hans Holbein the Younger in the Basel town hall. Later that decade he returned to Stuttgart, but he is recorded in Basel again in the latter half of the 1780s. By the 1790s, Grooth was active in Memmingen, where he died in 1797.

The Picture: Acquired in 1922 as a work of Jacques-André-Joseph Aved (1702–66), this portrait of a woman with a parrot was initially claimed to represent the Marquise d’Éon, that is, the cross-dressing French secret agent, Charles d’Éon de Beaumont (1728–1810). Although the somewhat masculine features of the sitter bear a passing resemblance to likenesses of d’Éon, that identification is doubtful. The attribution to Aved was soon rejected by Georges Wildenstein (1923), and in 1948 Harry Wehle and Margaretta Salinger observed a similarity in style to the work of Johann Nikolaus Grooth (opinions noted in curatorial file), to whom the picture has since been attributed.

In the Museum’s picture, the fluid paint handling, warmly honeyed palette, and sympathetic characterization are indeed close to secured portraits by Grooth from his Swiss period, such as the Portrait of a Woman with a Bonbonnière of 1759 and the Self-Portrait of 1760 (both Kunstmuseum Basel). Grooth’s portraits of the Basel couple Markus Weiss and Margaretha Leissler of about 1759–65—the latter also depicted with a parrot—show comparable brushwork in the physiognomies and costumes (location unknown; see W. R. Staehelin, Basler Portraits aller Jahrhunderte, Basel, 1919–21, vol. 2, pl. 41). The sitter’s costume is typical of the third quarter of the eighteenth century. Thus, the present work, which is most probably by Grooth, likely dates about 1760–75.

In the painting’s modern history, the parrot and cage were hidden beneath a layer of overpaint until they were revealed during a cleaning in 1938. Although the parrot, an exotic pet, was probably included primarily as a status symbol, it may have been painted out by a straitlaced former owner who was embarrassed by the traditional sexual connotations of the uncaged bird.

[Joshua P. Waterman 2013]
[Édouard Jonas, New York, until 1922]
"Accessions and Notes." Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 18 (January 1923), pp. 18–19, attributes it to Jacques André Joseph Aved and states that it is said to be a portrait of the marquise d'Eon.

Georges Wildenstein. Letter to Harry B. Wehle. May 31, 1923, rejects the attribution to Aved.

Georges Wildenstein. Letter to Harry B. Wehle. July 9, 1938, calls it rather mediocre and suggests an attribution to "un artiste comme Melle Allais ou même d'autres peintres dont les noms sont à peu près oubliés et dont les oeuvres sont difficilement identifiables".

Aileen Ribeiro. Dress in Eighteenth-Century Europe, 1715–1789. London, 1984, p. 104, fig. 62, as by J. G. [sic?] Grooth; discusses the painted silk morning dress.

Related Objects

Nymph and Shepherd

Artist: Johann Liss (German, Oldenburg ca. 1595/1600–1631 Verona) Date: ca. 1625 Medium: Oil on canvas Accession: 1999.121 On view in:Gallery 631

Two Men Contemplating the Moon

Artist: Caspar David Friedrich (German, Greifswald 1774–1840 Dresden) Date: ca. 1825–30 Medium: Oil on canvas Accession: 2000.51 On view in:Gallery 807

Parochialstrasse in Berlin

Artist: Eduard Gaertner (German, Berlin 1801–1877 Zechlin) Date: 1831 Medium: Oil on canvas Accession: 2006.258 On view in:Gallery 807

Gothic Windows in the Ruins of the Monastery at Oybin

Artist: Carl Gustav Carus (German, Leipzig 1789–1869 Dresden) Date: ca. 1828 Medium: Oil on canvas Accession: 2007.192 On view in:Gallery 807

Johann Joachim Winckelmann (1717–1768)

Artist: Anton Raphael Mengs (German, Ústi nad Labem (Aussig) 1728–1779 Rome) Date: ca. 1777 Medium: Oil on canvas Accession: 48.141 On view in:Not on view